Holy Wood (in the shadow of the valley of death) analysis
- Release date: November 13, 2000
- Genre: Rock
- Length: 68:19
- Label: Nothing, Interscope
- Written by: Marilyn Manson, Twiggy Ramirez, John 5, M. W. Gacy
Track List
Marilyn Lyrics | Music | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Marilyn Manson | Marilyn Manson | Twiggy Ramirez | John 5 | M.W. Gacy | |
Godeatgod | X | X | |||
The Love Song | X | X | X | ||
The Fight Song | X | X | |||
Disposable Teens | X | X | X | ||
Target Audience (Narcissus Narcosis) | X | X | X | ||
"President Dead" | X | X | X | X | |
In The Shadow of The Valley of Death | X | X | X | ||
Cruci-Fiction in Space | X | X | X | X | |
A Place in The Dirt | X | X | |||
The Nobodies | X | X | X | ||
The Death Song | X | X | X | ||
Lamb of God | X | X | |||
Born Again | X | X | |||
Burning Flag | X | X | X | X | |
Coma Black: a) Eden Eye, b) The Apple of Discord | X | X | X | ||
Valentine's Day | X | X | X | ||
The Fall of Adam | X | X | X | ||
King Kill 33° | X | X | |||
Count To Six and Die (The Vacuum of Infinite Space Encompassing) | X | X |
Introduction
On April 20, 1999, Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold, two high school students at Columbine High School in Colorado, arrived at the school armed with multiple firearms and a collection of improvised explosives, intending to kill as many people as possible. Though not all aspects of their plan worked (for example, the bombs that were meant for the cafeteria failed to detonate), they still managed to execute the worst school shooting in American history up to that point, with 13 dead and 24 injured. The event ended with the pair committing suicide.
In the moral panic that ensued, a rumor came up that the two were fans of Marilyn Manson and was widely propagated by the media. Even though it later came out that they weren't Marilyn Manson fans at all, and in fact even disliked his music, by then the damage has already been done, as America found its scapegoat for the tragedy.
The effect on Manson was quite severe. Years later he characterized this event as something that nearly ruined his career. He cancelled the remainder of his North America tour and had to pursue legal action against news outlets that carelessly continued to perpetuate the rumor that the shooters were Manson fans even after it was already found to be untrue. While controversy was high, Manson refused to give any interviews, and overall retreated from public view. But he also knew that eventually, he'll have to return to the spotlight and have an answer to the accusations. Holy Wood was that answer; one that pointed the finger at the proliferation of violence in American culture, and at the media for giving a voice to those who are willing to do terrible things to get noticed.
Setting and Story
The album's setting features two different worlds. One is Holy Wood, the world of mainstream society, the in-group everybody wants to be a part of because it's the dominant culture. Its culture is one of religion and violence, where people who die on TV receive so much attention from the media, it becomes indistinguishable from religious worship. Some of the revered dead personalities Holy Wood is obsessed with include JFK, John Lennon, and Jesus Christ.
On the opposite end there's Death Valley, the world of society's outcasts, the pitiful nobodies who couldn't find a place in Holy Wood. These are the people who develop a desperation-fueled resentment over having no future in this world, and who are eventually driven to acts of violence. It's the place people like Mark David, Lee Oswald, Charles Manson, and the Columbine shooters come from.
The story follows Adam, a denizen of Death Valley, as he tries to figure out how to live in this world. At first Adam wants to be a part of the glamor of Holy Wood, and feels terrible inadequacy for not fitting in. But after breaking through into that world, he realizes that the grass isn't greener on the other side, and that the people around him are the same assholes that have been keeping him down all his life. Resentment swells inside, and his initial reaction is to try to change the world, only to see his revolution watered down into a product. When the corruption of the world finally costs him the thing that he values the most- the woman he loves, his resentment becomes murderous, and he follows in the footsteps of Oswald, Mark David, and the Columbine killers, resolute to make the world pay.
Origin of the Death Valley
The album's subtitle "In the shadow of the valley of death", the similarly named 7th song, and first section of the track list, all make a reference to Psalms 23, verse 4:
1 The Lord is my shepherd; I shall not want.
2 He maketh me to lie down in green pastures: he leadeth me beside the still waters.
3 He restoreth my soul: he leadeth me in the paths of righteousness for his name's sake.
4 Yea, though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death, I will fear no evil: for thou art with me; thy rod and thy staff they comfort me.
5 Thou preparest a table before me in the presence of mine enemies: thou anointest my head with oil; my cup runneth over.
6 Surely goodness and mercy shall follow me all the days of my life: and I will dwell in the house of the Lord for ever.
The Death Valley is also a reference to Charles Manson, an individual Manson has a well-documented interest in.
Charles Manson was a crazy criminal who in the 60s led a hippie cult of misfits to commit murder. He prophesized that African Americans were about to begin a race war against whites, and that his group of hippies will survive it by hiding in a secret underground city beneath Death Valley, which is a real place in California. When time went by and the war didn't seem to be starting, Charles sent some of his cult members on multiple missions to commit murder and make it look racially motivated to "show the blacks how to do it". He and his cult were apprehended by law enforcement as they tried to run away to Death Valley.
Proof that Marilyn Manson had the Charles Manson murders in mind comes from multiple interviews, such as the one with Hotpress where he said:
So, the valley of death is the place misfits come from, and we are in its shadow because the threat from the misfits that society creates forever looms over us. Just as Charles Manson's cult was a group of misfits that meted out violence upon the world that rejected them, so did Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold take vengeance for their outcast status on their school mates.
As for the biblical angle, Psalms 23 is a poem that speaks of the comfort of being God's follower, and how it gets you through tough periods in your life. It is the basis for The Lord Is My Shepherd prayer, which is often uttered in funerals, a fact that connects us to the tragedy of the Columbine shootings. You could say that there were two versions to the story of the Columbine shootings: the one which the denizens of Holy Wood saw, for whom this was an unexpected tragedy that came out of nowhere. A society in the grace of God that suddenly found itself in the shadow of death. Then there is the other version, the one Manson as a public commentator was seeing: you weren't in the shadow of death… You were in the shadow of Death Valley; the shadow of the outcasts that you yourself created.
The protagonist: Adam vs Adam Kadmon vs Adam Rishon
The protagonist of the story of Holy Wood is called Adam. There are multiple references in the Holy Wood era to a being called Adam Kadmon, which means "primordial man", or "primal man". These references include:
- Manson's official BBS (bulletin board system, the precursor for internet forums) featured a graphic of Adam Kadmon during the Holy Wood era.
- In the same official BBS, right next to the image of Adam Kadmon, was the Kabbalistic Tree of Life, which also appears in the album artwork. The Tree of Life is associated with Adam Kadmon (see artwork section for more information).
These clues, and a general lack of distinction between Adam Kadmon and Adam Rishon (the Adam of the Garden of Eden story), led many people to conclude that the protagonist of the story is supposed to be Adam Kadmon. In my opinion, this is an incorrect interpretation.
First of all, Adam Kadmon is not a physical being. He is an archetype, a blueprint for humanity from which all humans are built, so our protagonist can't be Adam Kadmon because Adam Kadmon is an abstraction, not a real person. Second, the album also features associations to a different Adam, the Adam of Genesis:
- The song name The Fall of Adam is an obvious allusion to the biblical fall of Adam in Genesis.
- The artwork features references to Milton's Paradise Lost, where the story of Adam and Eve is a major plot element.
- Adam of Genesis is said to have been made from the earth. This is referenced in the 3rd section of the song list, called "of red earth".
- In some Jewish traditions it is believed that Adam of Genesis was initially created as an androgynous creature, which is why God was able to extract Eve from him. This is referenced in the 2nd section of the song list, called "the androgyn".
The Adam of Genesis is not the same "being" as Adam Kadmon. Rather, he is "Adam Rishon", the first physical human, made from Adam Kadmon's blueprint. Our Adam can't be Adam Rishon either, since the story of Holy Wood happens many years after Genesis. So if our Adam is neither Adam Kadmon, nor Adam Rishon, what kind of Adam is he?
I think that Holy Wood's Adam is his own character, and that both Adam Kadmon and Adam Rishon are artistic references that are invoked in the story through the shared name. Holy Wood's Adam is associated with the Genesis Adam because his story follows a similar theme of starting from a state of innocence and then falling out of "heaven" (or what he thought was heaven). Holy Wood's Adam is associated with Adam Kadmon in the sense that he is built from Adam Kadmon's blueprint, and Manson uses this fact to make the statement that violence is part of human nature. This idea can be seen in promotional photos for the Holy Wood era, where we can see Manson as Adam Kadmon holding a gun. Since Adam Kadmon is humanity's blueprint, the fact that he is holding a gun means that violence is part of humanity's blueprint. The idea that this image represents Adam Kadmon is based on the following clues:
- The Mercury symbol ☿. Mercury is associated with the intellect, which is why it's on his forehead, but it is also alchemically associated with Adam Rishon, who is often considered to be the first alchemist. At first glance, this isn't making my case, since it's referring to the wrong Adam. However, on the shoulder that Manson is covering with a gun there's a symbol for sublimation 🝞 (this can be seen in other photos from this photoshoot). The combination of sublimation and Mercury gives us Mercury Sublimate 🜐, the "higher", or transcendent, variety of Mercury. In other words, this is not the physical Adam Rishon, it's the spiritual Adam Kadmon.
- In this photoshoot Manson is not just bald, but hairless in general. This is because hair is not part of the blueprint of man, it's what we start to grow after we spawn in the world, just like how babies are born hairless.
Recurring Themes
Revolution and Evolution
Evolution and revolution are recurring themes in the album. Evolution is usually mentioned in the context of comparing man to ape, with the main point being that evolved as we are, we haven't really progressed very far. We're still as unsophisticated and violent as the apes we evolved from.
The topic of revolution ties in with the themes of the album on multiple levels. It comes up in the way people with revolutionary ideas often become martyred for standing up for those ideas. Jesus Christ is the quintessential example of that. Another example that is featured in the album is John Lennon. The subject of revolution also comes up as a plot element of the album's story: when Adam realizes that the world he so desperately wanted to fit-in is corrupt, it evokes a desire in him to change the world.
Murderers on TV, the makers of divine martyrs
The album features many references to famous killings: the Columbine massacre, the assassination of JFK, the assassination of John Lennon, and the crucifixion of Jesus Christ. Sometimes this is done to point out that violence is part of our cultural mythology, sometimes it's done to examine why someone might do such a thing, and sometimes it's done to point out the power of TV. A key point that Manson makes on the album is that when the media televises tragedies like the Columbine massacre, or the assassination of Kennedy, it elevates the cultural status of everybody involved. The perpetrators get their 15 minutes of fame, and this sets an example to other desperate and resentful individuals, who learn that they can get noticed if they do something violent enough. Meanwhile, the deceased become the subject of societal obsession, so much that it begins to resemble religious worship, as if the deceased became god himself. Manson repeats this concept again and again throughout the record, that "the camera will make you god".
On the album, the most prominent martyrs are JFK and Jesus Christ.
JFK
John F. Kennedy was the 35th president of the United States. His family was very prominent in American politics for many years and was held in high esteem by the American public. You could say they were the closest thing America had to the United Kingdom's royal family. Although JFK was already an American icon in his own right, being a president and a member of a highly accomplished and influential family, his cultural status became elevated to even greater heights on November 22, 1963, when he was assassinated in Dallas while travelling in a presidential motorcade. What made the event particularly notorious, was the fact that by sheer chance, his assassination was captured on film by Abraham Zapruder, a clothing manufacturer who just wanted a clip of the president he voted for. Although Zapruder wasn't the only one who was filming and taking photographs on that day, his film features the most complete record of the event and includes a clear view of the headshot moment. This film became known as the Zapruder Film, and the headshot moment as Frame 313. The film was initially only published in selected stills, but was eventually aired on TV in full. The first TV broadcast of the whole film was done by Los Angeles station KTLA on February 14, 1969, which was Valentine's Day in the year Marilyn Manson was born.
The man implicated in the shooting was Lee Harvey Oswald, a US marine veteran. His motive was never properly ascertained, partly because he himself was assassinated two days after killing JFK. However, the report submitted by the Warren Commission, which was created to investigate the assassination, featured some speculation on his motives:
It is apparent, however, that Oswald was moved by an overriding hostility to his environment. He does not appear to have been able to establish meaningful relationships with other people. He was perpetually discontented with the world around him. Long before the assassination he expressed his hatred for American society and acted in protest against it. Oswald's search for what he conceived to be the perfect society was doomed from the start. He sought for himself a place in history - a role as the "great man" who would be recognized as having been in advance of his times.
The Warren Commission also concluded that Oswald was acting alone and was not part of any conspiracy. Many people refused to accept this finding, and the conspiracy theories about the assassination still persist to this day. The theories postulate the involvement of the CIA, the KGB, the Mafia, Vice President Lyndon B. Johnson, Cuban Prime Minister Fidel Castro, or any combination of those people and organizations.
The assassination of JFK is featured heavily on this album, mentioned in about one third of all the songs. Often when Manson talks about JFK, he calls him Jack, which is a common nickname for John. The reason for this is that the story of Jesus is also featured heavily on the album, and that story also has a character named John (the Baptist). Referring to JFK as Jack is done to avoid confusion between the two.
JFK is also often referred to as "the king". This is a reference to the conspiracy theory "King Kill 33", which claims that it was the Freemasons who assassinated JFK in order to perform the Killing of The King rite.
Jesus Christ
While in previous albums Manson took an antagonistic approach to Christianity, on Holy Wood he started drawing inspiration from it. Of all the people referenced on this album, Christ encompasses the largest number of Holy Wood's topics: being a revolutionary, being a martyr, being a celebrity, being an image of violence:
The cosmic egg
There are many alchemical and Kabbalistic references in the Holy Wood era. For the most part, these elements appear in the artwork and music videos, and will be discussed in those sections of this article. But there is one alchemical metaphor that made it into the lyrics and became a recurring metaphor, and that's the egg.
There seem to be two meanings to the egg, which together capture the recurring idea in Holy Wood that dying on TV makes you into a god. First, the egg represents the frailty of human beings. On the song Godeatgod the egg is mentioned in reference to JFK being shot in the head, and in Coma Black it's in reference to breaking someone's heart. Both cases are described as fatal, something that cannot be repaired, much like how there is no way to mend a broken egg. In 2016, Manson posted this image to social media that is a pretty good illustration of a broken egg being a representation of death:
The Egg with smooth arrogant completeness, trembles in the green plastic-pagan grass. This is why the Rabbit crushes him...And a martyr is born.
--Instagram post caption
Although this image was posted many years after the release of Holy Wood, it's possible that Manson was aware of this illustration much earlier, and the image's Instagram caption does mention martyrdom, one of the main themes on the album. At the very least, even if no connection exists between this image and the album, it's still a nice representation of how the broken egg imagery works to represent being broken beyond repair.
The second meaning of the egg metaphor lies in the album's connection to alchemy. Eggs have a history of being used in alchemy, mysticism, and mythology to represent the mysteries of the world. Some of those uses appear in the album artwork:
The meaning of the egg that I believe is most relevant to the album lies in the mythology of the cosmic egg, a concept Manson is familiar with, having mentioned it in a Holy Wood era interview, and also tattooed it on his body. The cosmic egg is a motif in world creation myths of many proto-Indo-European cultures. In those cosmogonic stories, the world, or the gods, come into existence by hatching from an egg.
In conclusion: death is a breaking of an egg, and when the egg "breaks", a god is born.
Relationship to the Triptych
The albums Antichrist Superstar, Mechanical Animals, and Holy Wood, comprise the trinity of albums that Manson and the fans call "the triptych". The idea of the triptych is that there's supposedly a coherent story that is told across the three albums, one that was planned by Manson ahead of time. In actuality, there's pretty much no hard evidence that the albums were premeditated. All of them seem to be a product of whatever was going on in Manson's life at the time, which is to say based on events that Manson couldn't possibly have anticipated.
Over the years of working on the triptych, Manson changed the way he viewed its chronology. At the time of Holy Wood's release, he conceptualized the album to be the beginning of the story. This is reflected in naming the protagonist "Adam", a name strongly associated with the story of Genesis, the beginning of the world, as well as Manson drawing inspiration from the year of his birth, his own beginning:
Song Analysis
A: In The Shadow
This section describes the things that are in the shadow [...of Death Valley]. In other words, it's an exposition piece about the cultural setting of the story, a society where revolution ends in martyrdom, death is broadcast on TV, and teenagers who were once eager to fit in, but were rejected and discarded, are ready for a fight.
Godeatgod
The title of this song is a play on the phrase "dog eat dog", which means fierce competition where people are willing to do anything for success, even if it means hurting someone else. Replacing "dog" with "god" takes that cruelty and frames it in the concept of martyrdom, which on this album, is how one achieves godlike status in society.
In an interview with Kerrang magazine, Manson said that this song is "loosely about the character of Adam. The song is about him contemplating things from Death Valley". We can surmise from this that the narrator in this song is Adam, who is watching a martyr-crucifixion happening.
The song opens with a distorted sample of the sounds that seal the album: a revolver being cocked and fired, and the sound of fireworks. It reflects the idea that this is a recurring story, a cycle that repeats itself. Upon first listening, it acts as foreshadowing.
Lyrics | Commentary |
---|---|
Dear god do you want to tear your knuckles down and hold yourself Dear god can you climb off that tree Meat in the shape of a 'T' | We begin at a scene of crucifixion. The "meat in the shape of a T" refers to the shape of
the body when it's hanging on a cross. The line "can you climb off that tree" mirrors the
mocking of Jesus at his crucifixion:"So! You who are going to destroy the temple and build it in three days, come down from the cross and save yourself!" Referring to the cross as a tree ties us to the themes of evolution and ape vs. man that appear throughout the album. The idea here is that the worship of violence, which is inherent in the worship of a crucified figure, is a less evolved form of behavior, closer to ape than to man. Dear god do you want to tear your knuckles down and hold yourself The crucified god is a revolutionary, just like how Jesus Christ was a revolutionary. The first line talks about "tearing knuckles down", implying that they're currently raised up. The imagery that is hinted at is one of a raised fist, which is often used as a symbol for revolutionary resistance. The question "do you want to tear your knuckles down" therefore asks the crucified God if he wants to lay down his arms, so to speak, and give up on his revolution. In a world where being a revolutionary often leads to being a martyr, it's an understandable proposition to consider. |
Dear god the paper says you were the king in the black limousine | This is a reference to JFK, who was assassinated while riding in his black limousine. In
Manson's work, and especially in Holy Wood, the significance of dying on TV is that you
become a martyr, and a symbol, achieving an almost religious level of cultural status. Hence,
he is referred to as "dear god". Calling JFK a king is of course appropriate in the sense that he was the president of the United States, and in Democracy that's a position that is most analogous to a king in a Monarchy. However, it is also inspired by the essay King-Kill/33: Masonic Symbolism in the Assassination of John F. Kennedy, written by the conspiracy theorist James Shelby. It's an essay that postulates that it was the freemasons who assassinated JFK in order to enact the Killing of The King rite. |
Dear John and all the King's men Can't put your head together again | This line is a reference to Humpty Dumpty, an anthropomorphized egg from an English nursery
rhyme:Humpty Dumpty sat on a wall. As mentioned in the introduction section, eggs on this album represent both the frailty of mortality, and the thing from which gods are born, and this metaphor ties all of that together. JFK died by a shot to the head. Like the broken Humpty Dumpty, he could never be put together again. Like Humpty Dumpty, his death was a breaking of the egg. From the broken egg JFK-the-god emerged. Who is John? Since this is a scene of crucifixion, which is strongly associated with the story of Jesus, the most appropriate interpretation is John the Baptist, one of Jesus' disciples, who can be thought of as being Jesus' second in command due to his unique status of being chosen by God. In Matthew 11:11 Jesus calls him the greatest of all men: Truly I tell you, among those born of women there has not risen anyone greater than John the Baptist |
Before the bullets Before the flies Before authorities take out my eyes The only smiling are you dolls that I made But you are plastic and so are your brains | The scene of the crucifixion is the end of a story (hence the repetition of the word "before"),
a story of bullets, flies, and being blinded by authorities. Perhaps, there used to be a
time when things didn't have to end this way? This verse is best viewed as being from the point of view of the crucified god, because it says, "authorities took out my eyes". Since Adam clearly has his eyes intact (literally and metaphorically), the speaker has to be someone else. This interpretation helps us understand the line about the dolls: The dolls are his followers, that's why he "made" them. Unfortunately, instead of a real movement, made of individuals who can think for themselves, he only managed to make a crowd of mindless dolls, so his attempt at a revolution failed. His dolls are smiling because only the mindless ones can find happiness in this world. |
Dear god the sky is as blue As a gunshot wound Dear god if you were alive You know we'd kill you | Violence is everywhere, and for a society that worships violence, even their relationship with God is all about the ritual of violence. |
Before the bullets Before the flies Before authorities take out my eyes The only smiling are you dolls that I made But you are plastic and so are your brains |
The Love Song
In an interview with Kerrang magazine, Manson said this about the song:
In this song, a child is represented by a bullet, who is in love with the society where he wants to fit in. The hand and pistol that end up firing the bullet are either the society that rejects the bullet, or the parents that raised the bullet, depending on how you want to look at the lyrics.
Samples
The song ends with this sample: "Maybe it's the best night... I think he should have done... twelve hail Marys... get long..." Source unknown.
Lyrics | Commentary |
---|---|
[The bullet:] "I've got a crush on a pretty pistol Should I tell her that I feel this way? Father told us to be faithful I've got a crush on a pretty pistol Should I tell her that I feel this way I've got love songs in my head That are killing us away" | In an interview for MTV, Manson said this about the song:The love song is one of the most common titles in music, and I wanted to make a metaphor about guns, and I was suggesting with the lyrics that the father is the hand, the mother is the gun, and the children are the bullets. Where you shoot them is your responsibility as parents. There is, indeed, some of that going on in the song. The bullet in the lyrics is clearly the kid, and we are seeing one of the first instances in Manson's lyrics of giving guns a feminine identity (got a crush on a pretty pistol, should I tell her that I feel this way?), so the mother must be a gun too, and that would leave the father the job of being the hand. However, there's more going on in the song than just that. Since the bullet has a crush on a pretty pistol, that pistol can't be his mother, so who is she? Given the theme of the album, the best interpretation seems to be society. The bullet has a crush on the pistol in the sense that he wants to fit-in with society, and when that society rejects the bullet- expels it from itself- it's akin to that pistol firing the bullet. |
[The Father:] "Do you love your guns?" (Yeah) "God?" (Yeah) "The government?" "Do you love your guns?" (Yeah) "God?" (Yeah) "The government?" (Fuck yeah) | Throughout the song we see examples of the parents guiding their child. In the previous verse the father told the child to be faithful, and in the next verse the mother tries to shield her child from the horrors of the world by telling him to look away... But it's here in the chorus where the meat of the bad parenting is at. |
The bullet: "She tells me I'm a pretty bullet I'm gonna be a star someday Mother says that we should look away She tells me I'm a pretty bullet An Imitation Christ I've got love songs in my head That are killing us away" | She tells me I'm a pretty bullet These are the rotten seeds that are planted in the head of the bullet. An expectation of greatness, and Christ as the ideal to imitate. The combination of the two gives us greatness through martyrdom. |
The Father: "Do you love your guns?" (Yeah) "God?" (Yeah) "The government?" (Fuck yeah) |
The Fight Song
In an interview with Kerrang magazine, Manson said this about the song:
Lyrics | Commentary |
---|---|
Nothing suffocates you more than the passing of everyday human events Isolation is the oxygen mask you make your children breathe into survive But I'm not a slave to a god That doesn't exist I'm not a slave to a world That doesn't give a shit And when we were good You just closed your eyes So when we are bad We'll scar your minds Fight, fight, fight, fight | Nothing to comment, very straightforward lyrics. |
You'll never grow up to be a big-rock-star-celebrated-victim-of-your-fame They'll just cut our wrists like Cheap coupons and say that death Was on sale today | You'll never grow up to be a big-rock-star-celebrated-victim-of-your-fame Manson associates the rock star with being a rebel, so that's the "tries to make a revolution through music" angle he talked about in the interview quoted above. But in this society, his attempts will be crushed before he even gets started. This says something about the way society treats people with dangerous revolutionary ideas, but it is also a statement that there is no future for misfits, because the out-of-mainstream path will be unavailable for them. They'll just cut our wrists like To add insult to injury, Manson suggests that their future is being "sold for cheap". Society doesn't even get much benefit from robbing them of their future, it does it only for the sake of denying them. |
And when we were good You just closed your eyes So when we are bad We'll scar your minds But I'm not a slave to a god that doesn't exist I'm not a slave to a world that doesn't give a shit | |
The death of one is a tragedy But the death of millions is just a statistic. | This sentence is often misattributed to Joseph Stalin, though the true origin is the novel
The Black Obelisk by German author Erich Maria Remarque. In an interview with
Metal Edge magazine Manson had this to say about this segment:I don't know what struck that specific comment, but I think it was inspired by how it's such a big deal when some person dies in such a dramatic way, then for some reason their death is more relevant than thousands of other people that die all the time. It's insulting that people make such a fuss over columbine and act like it's the first time it happened. People die in schools all the time, especially in the urban areas where it's just like a common occurrence. Kennedy was martyred because the production value of his murder was so grand, the cinematography was so well done. I think that's really where the root of that remark came from. |
Disposable Teens
This song is like the anthem of misfit teenagers. It describes their status in society, and their subsequent mentality towards that society. As an aside, it also hints at some generational tension, between the idealists of the 60s and 70s, and the children they ended up raising. This is something that is easy to miss, since the references are very subtle and ambiguous, and you can certainly interpret the entire song without addressing that aspect of it. However, Manson pointed it out in an interview with Metal Edge magazine:
Lyrics | Commentary |
---|---|
And I'm a black rainbow And I'm an ape of god I've got a face that's made for violence upon And I'm a teen distortion Survived abortion A rebel from the waist down | And I'm a black rainbow A black rainbow is a gloomy version of something that's supposed to be cheerful. It could represent the pessimistic phase that all teenagers go through where they suddenly hate everything and rebel against anything. And I'm an ape of God The "ape of God" is a nickname for Satan. The idea behind it is that the devil cannot do anything original, so he can only copy- "ape"- whatever God does. The speaker in the song is Satan in the sense that he is a "bad kid", but he is also an ape in the sense that he is inferior in the eyes of the God-ideal. I've got a face that's made for violence upon This implies that the speaker is getting bullied. and I'm a teen distortion "Survived abortion" implies that he was an unwanted child, and that his parents intended to abort him, but for whatever reason didn't go through with it. A rebel from the waist down This is a reference to the George Orwell classic novel 1984, a dystopian story that was written as a cautionary tale against the dangers of totalitarian regimes. In that story, the protagonist Winston has an affair with a woman named Julia. They both share a disdain for the establishment, which makes them thought criminals, and while neither of them is willing to oppose the establishment openly, their secret romance is itself an act of rebellion, since the totalitarian regime where they live has very puritanical morals regarding romantic relationships. While Winston is preoccupied with both the past, present, and future, often thinking about life before the regime, and worrying about the future they are headed to, Julia only cares about their relationship, causing Winston to quip that she's "only a rebel from the waist down". Within the context of the song, you can interpret it as "only a rebel when it's fun", meaning that the speaker isn't a true idealist who acts out of a set of strong principles. This could be an expression of the critical view the ex-hippie idealistic parents can have of their children's generation: "We believed in something; these kids just rebel for entertainment". An alternative interpretation is that the speaker is using their sexuality to rebel, possibly against sexual conservatism, although this interpretation ignores the origin of the phrase. |
I wanna thank you mom I wanna thank you dad For bringing this fucking world To a bitter end | One way to look at this is that it's a typical example of intergenerational fighting, with the kids blaming the parents for all of their mistakes that the kids end up paying for. But this becomes more scathing in light of the culture of idealistic desire for a revolution from the 60s and 70s that's being hinted at in the song. This bitter end is not merely a product of neglect, lack of knowledge, corruption, etc. No, this is the result of them trying to make things better. |
I never really hated the one true god, But the god of the people I hated | The line "I never really hated the one true god/ but the god of the people I hated"
references the quote "I did not hate God or Christ, but merely the God and Christ of the
people whom I hated" by Aleister Crowley. Aleister Crowley was an English occultist most notable for founding the Thelema branch of occultism. He was a controversial public figure in his time, once even branded as "the wickedest person on earth". |
You said you wanted evolution The ape was a great big hit You say you want a revolution man And I say that you're full of shit | This chorus has some similarities to The Beatles song Revolution:You say you want a revolution, This is the subtle reference that's thrown in the song about the generation of the parents. You said you wanted evolution Evolution and revolution are two recurring themes on this album. The concept of evolution generally comes up in the lyrics paired with the irony that despite being so "advanced", we're still as violent as the animals we evolved from. We may have wanted to evolve as far away from our ape ancestors as possible, but it doesn't seem like we evolved very far from them in practice. You say you want a revolution man The speaker doesn't believe that the call for a revolution is sincere. Indeed, the hippie generation that advocated for revolution during their naïve teenage years all ended up becoming just another cog in the societal machine, so they were no true revolutionaries. Alternatively, since one of the themes of this album is that you can't change the world, this phrase could be pointing out that idealistic drive for a revolution is doomed to failure. They're full of shit in the sense that they have no clue what they're talking about when they say they want to change the world. |
We're disposable teens We're disposable teens We're disposable You said you wanted evolution The ape was a great big hit You say you want a revolution, man And I say that you're full of shit | |
The more that you fear us The bigger we get The more that you fear us The bigger we get And don't be surprised, don't be surprised Don't be surprised when we destroy all of it | Any fear you avoid gets reinforced and grows. The more society fears these outcast children, the further it pushes them away, which makes them bigger outcasts, and more resentful. |
You said you wanted evolution The ape was a great big hit You say you want a revolution man And I say that you're full of shit We're disposable teens We're disposable teens We're disposable |
D: The Androgyn
There is an idea that comes from Jewish Midrash, specifically the Genesis Rabbah, an ancient text of rabbinical interpretations for the Book of Genesis, that postulates that Adam was created as an androgynous creature, which is why God was later able to separate him into man and woman. Manson's previous album Mechanical Animals featured an androgynous alien as a main character. The androgynous nature of the alien was meant to represent the idea that he doesn't fit in with anyone, since his androgyny makes him incompatible with both sexes. In summary, the androgyn is Adam, and the androgyn is a misfit. This suggests that this section is will be about Adam's point of view as a misfit, unlike the previous section which was more about describing the societal setting in general.
Target Audience (Narcissus Narcosis)
In an interview with Kerrang magazine Manson said that "[this song] to me is about being a nobody and wanting to be somebody". The song is written like a sarcastic apology for not fitting in with society. The speaker is clearly resentful of this fact, but being a pitiful anonymous, he can't do anything about it.
The song also discusses the role TV plays in shaping society. The name of the song, Target Audience, is a media term that refers to the demographic that the media tries to appeal to. The subtitle Narcissus Narcosis is also a media reference, this time for the work of Marshal McLuhan, a famous media analyst that Manson has a well-established fascination with. Chapter 4 of his book Understanding Media starts with a segment called "narcissus as narcosis", where McLuhan uses the story of Narcissus from Greek mythology as an introduction to the subject of the chapter. The idea of that chapter, called The Gadget Lover, is that depictions of ourselves outside of ourselves (for example the TV, or in Narcissus' case- his reflection in the water) numb us, and thus provide comfort that counteracts the various stresses that life imposes on us. In other words, TV induced numbness is a coping strategy. Together, the title and subtitle evoke the image of a society self-medicating through addiction to the media, which is controlled by "old deceivers", who know very well what they are doing when they target their audience. By invoking Marshal's work, Manson attempts to give insight into why the TV holds the power that it does.
So, to summarize, our speaker is a misfit who wishes he could be somebody, and he learns from watching TV that the media can make him be heard.
Lyrics | Commentary |
---|---|
Am I sorry your sky went black, put your knives in babies backs? Am I sorry you killed the Kennedy's, and Huxley too? | Am I sorry your sky went black, The second line is best read as: "How about you cope with your black sky by putting your knives in babies' backs?" In Manson's lyrics infanticide and abortion are generally metaphors for sabotaging the lives and futures of children. Sometimes, parents might consciously or unconsciously sabotage their children when the way they deal with an uncomfortable reality (black sky) conflict with the interest of the children. Am I sorry you killed the Kennedy's, and Huxley too? Aldus Huxley, who is most known for writing the dystopian novel Brave New World, died on the same day that JFK was murdered. Huxley was a highly influential writer, who was nominated nine times for the Nobel Prize in Literature, and was elected Champion of Literature by the Royal Society of Literature. Under normal circumstances, his death would've been headlining news, but instead, his death was completely overshadowed by JFK's assassination. The previous two lines in this verse had an element of blame (too bad your sky went black, how about you cope by taking it out on your children like you always do?), and this line does too, except that the blame is more implicit. An idea that appears later in the song Lamb of God, is that your death becomes insignificant if it happens off camera: If you die when there's no one watching ...and the degree to which it is a cultural failure by society is well illustrated by the fact that the death of a literary genius was completely forgotten, because everybody was busy focusing on the president's death. So, by mentioning Huxley, it's as if Manson is saying "and guess who you also should've paid attention to". |
But I'm sorry Shakespeare was your scapegoat and your apple's sticking into my throat Sorry your Sunday smiles are rusty nails and your crucifixion commercials failed but I'm just a pitiful anonymous | But I'm sorry Shakespeare was your scapegoat Society has a well-established history of blaming art for supposedly being a corrupting force, and this is a specific example of this trend. It's unclear to me why Shakespeare was chosen for this line, as I was unable to find any noteworthy stories of his work being blamed for something in modern times, although I can imagine some misguided parents blaming a story like Romeo and Juliette for encouraging teen suicide. and your apple's sticking into my throat This alludes to the Adam's Apple, the protrusion in the neck that some men have. One of the ancient explanations for the name Adam's Apple is that a piece from the forbidden fruit (which is often represented by an apple) got stuck in Adam's throat when he ate it, hence the protrusion. The apple therefore represents knowledge, or specifically- their knowledge. The speaker learned "their" (society's) knowledge, and now it's stuck in his throat like an uncomfortable truth. Sorry your Sunday smiles are rusty nails Sunday is church day, and in religious communities it becomes a day of socializing with your fellow neighbors as they all meet in church. Fake smiles and other acts of politeness are the expected etiquette, but our speaker sees them as grotesque. and your crucifixion commercials failed Manson often points out in interviews that he considers Christ to be the blueprint for celebrity, and that wearing a crucifix is not much different than wearing the shirt of your favorite band. Calling the crucifixion a commercial follows a similar line of thought. but I'm just a pitiful anonymous In a world where being on TV is what brings you recognition, being anonymous, the opposite of famous, is the ultimate status of isolation. |
And I see all the young believers Your target audience I see all the old deceivers and we all just sing their song | Old deceivers televise their message to young naïve believers who don't know any better and end up accepting the message (sing the song of the old deceivers). For the album's protagonist, this is a lesson in the power of television. |
Am I sorry just to be alive putting my face in the beehive? Am I sorry for Booth and Oswald, pinks and cocaine too? | As with the first verse, the first 4 lines follow a proposition-response format. This time
he is speaking about himself, how he feels like a burden to everybody (am I sorry just to be
alive, maybe I should just kill myself), and how he finds more kinship with society's villains
(Booth and Oswald) than society's role models, so maybe he should just drown himself in
drugs to cope... Booth is a reference to John Wilkes Booth, who assassinated Abraham Lincoln, and Oswald is a reference to Oswald Lee Harvey, who assassinated JFK. "Pinks" is pink heroin. |
I'm sorry you never check the bag in my head for a bomb and my halo was a needle hole Sorry I saw a priest being beaten and I made a wish but I'm just a pitiful anonymous | I'm sorry you never check Having a bomb in his head means he has devastating ideas. and my halo was a needle hole ...and I'm not holy enough for you (my halo is tiny). Sorry I saw a priest being beaten Generally, you make a wish upon things that are special. Blowing out birthday candles, seeing a falling star, paying tribute to the gods by throwing coins into a well. The speaker sees the beaten priest as a positive thing that brings luck, betraying a deep disdain for their role in society. |
And I see all the young believers Your target audience I see all the old deceivers we all just sing their song | |
"The valley of death we are free your father's your prison you see" | This is in quotes, so it's a statement, made by the denizens of Death Valley. From their
vantage point outside of society, they can see that the TV acts as a prison. It is a prison
because the viewers are its captive audience, and the idea that they are trapped by it is
the same idea that Marshall McLuhan describes in his Narcissus parable.The youth Narcissus mistook his own reflection in the water for another person. This extension of himself by mirror numbed his perceptions until he became the servomechanism of his own extended or repeated image. [...] He had adapted to his extension of himself and had become a closed system. You can interpret the second line to mean that it's a cross generational prison: their fathers were as trapped by it as the children are. But we can also tie it to the dichotomy of young believers and old deceivers, since the fathers are older than the children. This shifts the meaning to "it's a prison your fathers built and control, and where the children are now trapped". |
And I see all the young believers Your target audience I see all the old deceivers we all just sing their song | |
You're just a copy of an imitation | In a recorded statement
about the Columbine incident and violence in culture, Manson said that:We sit in front of the TV, and we are the TV. We're a copy staring at a copy, and a copy, and a copy. It's like the guy on Jerry Springer staring at the monitor to see if he sees himself, and it becomes a loop. Because you see it, and you see yourself again, and again, and again. So eventually it's a Xerox that's so degenerated we don't know which came first. When you let TV be your reality, and you relate to yourself through the content you see on TV, you become a copy of an imitation. |
Samples
The song ends with a sample "The president is dead. Let us pray."" It is taken from a WABC Radio broadcast by Don Gardiner, which confirmed JFK's death after previously reporting the shooting incident. It segues us to the next song.
"President Dead"
The name of this song is in reference to the headline that appeared in printed press covering the assassination of JFK.
This song has a duration of 3 minutes and 13 seconds. Frame 313 in the famous Zapruder Film is the precise frame in which JFK is shot. Manson said in interviews that this was a coincidence, but a welcome one.
This is a silly and humorous song with quirky imagery and word play. We have the dumbass President Dead, egg people, and God who is a piggy in a fair. Overall, the song pokes fun at the culture of violence where martyrdom and dead presidents are worshipped.
Lyrics | Commentary |
---|---|
This is for the people, they want you This is for the people, they want you Getting high on violence, baby | The phrase "for the people" is part of the presidential theme of this song, being one of
President Abraham Lincoln's most famous quotes, appearing in his Gettysburg Address:...that these dead shall not have died in vain—that this nation, under God, shall have a new birth of freedom-and that government of the people, by the people, for the people, shall not perish from the earth. |
President Dead is clueless and he's caught in a headlight, police-state god and his skull is stained glass | Notice the capitalization: President Dead. In this song Manson turns the phrase into a
character, a president whose name is Dead. This character is an idiot, based on the first
line where he is described as clueless, but also from the second line, where the phrase
"caught in a headlight" is reminiscent of the phrase "like a deer caught in the headlights".
Deer are notorious for getting run over by cars at night, because the appearance of the
headlights is so startling for them that they end up freezing in place, instead of running
out of the way. The phrase is used to describe someone who is so scared or surprised that
they cannot think. Describing the president as a police-state god implies that society is fascist. The president has risen to the status of divinity by being shot dead in the head, and now the image of his skull is depicted in stained glass artwork that decorates churches. |
Incubated and jet set The bitter thinkers buy their tickets to go find god like a piggy in a fair | The word "incubation" means keeping eggs in a suitable temperature so that they develop. This
word has been extrapolated to other things such as bacteria, embryos, development of diseases,
and more, but its etymology is specifically about birds sitting on eggs (from Latin incubat-
'lain on'). This makes me think that Manson intended to imagine the bitter thinkers in this
verse as egg people. An incubated egg-person would be someone who lives a sheltered life where
everything is organized for their thriving. In other words, someone privileged. "Jet set" means "wealthy and fashionable people who travel widely and frequently for pleasure". So, we are talking about privileged people who don't have any real problems. Why are these people bitter thinkers? It might be implying that they are cynics, but that wouldn't fit very well with the rest of the verse. These egg people are making a pilgrimage to see God, which hardly seems like something a cynic might do. Personally, I like to think that this is a veiled reference to Marshall McLuhan, a media analyst that Manson has a well-documented interest in, who wrote in an essay that can be found in the book Media Research: Technology, Art and Communication: People hope that if they scream loudly enough about 'values,' then others will mistake them for serious, sensitive souls who have higher and nobler perceptions than ordinary people. Otherwise, why would they be screaming? So, the bitter thinkers are moral bitter thinkers, aka idiots. I find this to be fitting with both the details of the lyrics and the overall mocking attitude of the song, though I must admit that without further corroboration this McLuhan connection remains a speculation. The privileged bitter thinkers buy a ticket to see God. This is a reference to the contemporary notion of "a ticket to heaven". The ticket is supposed to be earned through repentence and acceptance of Jesus Christ, but Manson describes what they do as "purchasing" a ticket, which is a cynical interpretation, but not an unreasonable one. If someone tells you that there's a reward for good deeds, you might do the deeds for the reward rather than desire to be good. In that sense, it's as morally vacuous as just purchasing the ticket with money. The idea that they go to heaven to find God in the same manner they might go to a fair to look at pigs suggests that their pilgrimage is devoid of any real spirituality. |
And we don't want to live forever And we know that suffering is so much better | For the wages of sin is death, but the free gift of God is eternal life in Christ Jesus our Lord. The "live forever" line refers to the gift of eternal life that God bestows upon those who follow Jesus Christ. The alternative is sin and eternal suffering in hell. Our speaker clearly wants nothing to do with the Christian mainstream way of life, even if it means choosing hell. |
This is for the people, they want you This is for the people, they want you Getting high on violence, baby | |
Give the pills time to work We all can't be martyred in the winter of our discontent (Getting high on violence, baby) | The term "winter of our discontent" comes from Shakespeare's play Richard III:Now is the winter of our discontent In the play, the phrase refers to discontent from the ascension of king Richard the 3rd. The phrase was coopted in more modern times to describe a period of civil unrest in the late 70s UK, that was characterized by widespread strikes of multiple trade unions. The line "we all can't be martyred..." is like saying "we all can't afford to fix our problems with If we accept the trade union strike reference, the full phrase becomes "we all can't afford to fix our problems by martyring ourselves for an idealistic cause". |
Every night we are nailed into place and every night we just can't seem to ever remember the reason why (Getting high on violence, baby) | "Nailed into place" naturally evokes the nailing of Jesus to the cross, although it could also be a general description of being put in a position where you are stuck. The stupid masses don't even know why they do the things they do, even when those things are detrimental to them. |
And we don't want to live forever And we know that suffering is so much better This is for the people, they want to This is for the people, they want to Getting high on violence, baby And we don't want to live forever And we know that suffering is so much better |
In The Shadow of The Valley of Death
In this song, Adam laments the fact that he doesn't fit in, and how lonely and worthless it makes him feel.
Lyrics | Commentary |
---|---|
We have no future heaven wasn't made for me we burn ourselves to hell as fast as it can be and I wish that I could be the king then I'd know that I am not alone | A lot of the song is self-explanatory, but one line that's worth addressing in this verse is:and I wish that I could be the king The fact that the speaker sees becoming the king as a cure for his loneliness says something about the kind of role models he grew up with. There are other ways to cure loneliness, like being part of a community, or interpersonal relationships, even getting a pet. But our protagonist grew up watching the president on TV, being adored by the masses, and this is the example he has to follow. |
Maggots put on shirts sell each other shit sometimes I feel so worthless sometimes I feel discarded I wish that I was good enough then I'd know that I am not alone | |
Death is policeman Death is the priest Death is the stereo Death is a TV Death is the Tarot Death is an angel and Death is our God killing us all | Death is everywhere and everything. It's our public servants, it's in our media, it's in our spirituality, and it's the thing we worship. |
she put the seeds in me plant this dying tree she's a burning string and I'm just the ashes | Given that the subject of the song is Adam's relationship with society, I think that it's
best to interpret the "she" as the same "she" that the speaker had a crush on in The Love
Song. Society put in him a desire to fit in, and it was a desire that was destined to fail,
therefore the only thing that could've grown out of that seed is something dead. Society is the too bright, too hot, thing of awe you can never touch, and he's just whatever it discards behind itself. |
Cruci-Fiction In Space
The name of this song comes from the book Monumental Christianity, by John P. Lundy. This is a scholarly book that studies the art and symbolism of early Christian church. In chapter 7, The Good Shepherd, Lundy points out that the story of Jesus has parallels in many pre-Christianity stories. One way in which Lundy demonstrates it, is by discussing a Hindu art piece, which is reproduced in Holy Wood's artwork:
Of this image, Lundy wrote the following:
The notion that the victim-savior archetype is universal, and thus appears in multiple mythologies, connects to multiple ideas in this song. The first idea is the innate nature of violence. Just as we've been killing each other since the dawn of time, way before we had Rock music, video games, and TV to "inspire" such behavior, so does the appeal of martyrdom seems to be primeval. In fact, it seems like we didn't even need Christianity for it to be invented. Second, there's the "cruci-fiction" word play, which addresses the idea that this is a recurring story. It recurs in world mythologies, as it does in real life. In this song, Manson embraces this concept to write some of his own "fan fiction" about what a modern-day gospel of Jesus Christ would've been like.
Lyrics | Commentary |
---|---|
This is evolution The monkey The man And then the gun | On the record, I talk a lot about the irony of how man has come so far but has learned so little. And I tried to use those three words as emblems to represent those points in time, and how ironic it is that even though we have so much knowledge at our fingertips, we're still behaving like Cain and Abel. And also the irony of the gun and how even though it's the gun that hurts, man would hurt himself anyway, even without it. So I try to bring up those points in evolution. |
If Christ was in Texas The hammer The sickle The only son | Texas is the state where JFK was assassinated. The hammer and sickle is the symbol of communism. In his days, Christ was considered a political rival by the establishment, so in order for him to be that role in Texas he would have to be (or accused of being by the establishment) a commie. That would've been his title along with being God's only son. |
This is your creation The atom of Eden Was a bomb | This seems to be a reference to the "primordial atom", the tiny clump of infinitely dense
energy that exploded into the big bang. Here Manson connects it to the Old Testament
mythology of world creation by calling it the atom of Eden. The idea here is that violence was in the world literally from its inception, since the very act of world creation was a bomb exploding. This fits with the message in the beginning of the verse, where Manson is saying that violence is still part of our nature despite of how evolved we are. Basically, humanity is as violent as it has ever been, and the universe is as violent as it has ever been. |
If Jack was the Baptist We'd drink wine From his head | John F. Kennedy was also called Jack by those who were close to him, as Jack is a common
nickname for John. John the Baptist was one of Jesus' disciples. He forecasted the arrival of Jesus, saying: "I will baptize you with water for repentance, but he who is coming after me is mightier than I, whose sandals I am not worthy to carry. He will baptize you with the Holy Spirit and fire." John the Baptist was beheaded by Herod Antipas, the tetrarch of Galilee and Perea, on the request of Herodias' daughter. His head then went on a complicated journey of being hidden and discovered, moved from place to place, and changing multiple owners. Today, two Catholic churches, one mosque, and one museum in Germany, all claim to have the head of John. Drinking wine that represents blood is part of the holy communion ritual. Its symbolic meaning is that it represents the blood of Jesus, the holiest man to ever walk the Earth. Taken together, Manson is suggesting that if the story of Jesus would've happened in modern day Texas, and JFK was the Baptist character, he would've become way more holy than Jesus himself, because unlike Jesus, JFK died on TV. Then, instead of his head being the subject of a historical capture-the-flag race, it would've become the subject of the holy communion ritual. In other words, this is a statement about the power of TV, that it can overshadow even the son of God. It's interesting to note that JFK was a Catholic, not a Baptist, so this might be what inspired the "if he was the Baptist" comparison, as well as the fact that both men were killed in a manner that involved their head. So, to conclude the little gospel fanfic in this verse, if Christ and JFK the Baptist were in Texas, Christ would've been branded a commie, and JFK would've become the subject of worship for losing his head on TV, instead of the actual son of God becoming the subject of worship. |
This is evolution The monkey The man And then the gun | |
I am a revolution Pull my knuckles down if I could I am a revelation And I'm nailed to the Holy Wood | We are now at the scene of another crucifixion. Not the mythological crucifixion of Jesus,
but one of the Holy Wood crucifixions, where another revolutionary becomes a martyr for his
cause. It is narrated by the crucified revolutionary, who describes himself in a manner
reminiscent of the song Godeatgod, where he is asked if he can pull his knuckles down:Dear God do you want to tear your knuckles down, and hold yourself? The holy wood he is nailed to is the crucifix. He is both a revolution, and a revelation to all those who see him on the cross. |
This is evolution The monkey The man And then the gun | |
We are dead and tomorrow's canceled Because of things we did yesterday We are dead and tomorrow's canceled They crucify us in our space In our space In our space... | Here we have a general description of how sin works. Having sinned in the past disgraces us
in the present and prevents our entry into the kingdom of God in the future. Some of us are
then chosen to be crucified to pay the price for the abolition of these sins. Why is it done
in "our" space? When Lundy named the image that he saw in Moor's Hindu Pantheon "crucifixion in space", he was reacting to the manner in which this quintessential symbol of Christianity was depicted in isolation from any background context. This demonstrates a universal quality of the crucified martyr, since he is recognizable as-is, without any additional information. In other words, the specifics can be anything, Hindu, Christian, or otherwise, but the underlying symbol remains the same. It also happens to be the case that mythological characters tend to be celestial beings, and Lundy was most likely using the word "space" to mean "the heavens", rather than outer space (the usage of the word "space" to refer to outer space was popularized multiple decades after Lundy published his work on Christianity). Suffice to say that every culture, every mythology, has its own version of the heavens wherein the supernatural resides. There is always a space in which an incarnation of the crucified god resides. |
This is evolution The monkey The man And then the gun | |
...flies are waiting | Flies are attracted to carcasses. This is a foreshadowing. There will be blood. |
A Place in The Dirt
In this song, the speaker descends into nihilism, and begins to develop a relationship with death, the only thing of beauty he can see in an ugly world. Inspired by JFK's death, he is ready to become another celebrity who dies on TV.
Lyrics | Commentary |
---|---|
We are damned and we are dead all god's children to be sent to our perfect place in the sun and in the dirt | The phrase "a place in the sun" means "a very good, successful, or desirable position", like being a martyr. A place in the dirt is an allusion to being dead, as the ground is where we bury people. |
There's a windshield in my heart we are bugs so smeared and scarred and could you stop the meat from thinking before I swallow all of it, could you please? | The speaker descends to nihilism. Humans are just insignificant insects to him. Their deaths,
represented by being smeared on a car windshield, do not impact him, since the windshield
keeps them away from his heart. Likewise, the animals he eats are just meat to him. He begins to develop a relationship with death. His request to stop the meat from thinking is a call to slaughter. He consumes their death. |
Put me in the motorcade put me in the death parade dress me up and make me dress me up and make me your dying god | The motorcade is another reference to JFK, who was guarded by a motorcade while he was riding the limousine in which he got shot. Once again, we see the speaker wishing to be treated like Kennedy, with all that it entails. |
angel with needles poked through our eyes and let the ugly light of the world in and we were no longer blind and we were no longer blind | Angels are the good guys, and their gift of sight is supposed to be a blessing. Yet for the speaker, not only is the giving of sight a painful event (eyes poked with needles), it's also nothing but a curse, since all he can see is ugliness. This suggests a real inability to have a positive relationship with the good and is a description of hopeless nihilism. |
Put me in the motorcade put me in the death parade dress me up and make me dress me up and make me your dying god | |
Now we hold the "ugly head" the Mary-whore is at the bed They've cast the shadow of our perfect death in the sun and in the dirt. | Now we hold the "ugly head" When something "raises its ugly head", it means that something bad is happening again. Since we hold the ugly head, it means we are the ones raising it. What is this "it" that we're raising once again? "It" is the birth of another Christ. It's expressed in the chorus by the speaker's desire to be in the motorcade, but it is also hinted at in the next line. The ugly head is also a reference to Kennedy. The name Kennedy is derived from the Gaelic O'Cinneide, which in turn is derived from cean eidig, meaning "ugly head". This piece of trivia appears in the conspiratorial article King Kill 33, which is referenced in the similarly named song later in the album. the Mary-whore is at the bed The Mary prostitute is a character in the story of Jesus. She's at the bed, which is the appropriate place for a prostitute to be at. In other words, she's in position to play her role. This is like saying that the actors in a play are "in position" to start the play. We are ready for another acting of the martyr story. |
A: Of Red Earth
The Hebrew word "Adamah" means "earth" (the ground, not the planet). The Hebrew word "Adom" means
"red". Adam, Adamah, and Adom all have the same Hebrew root (אדם), meaning they are etymologically
connected. This connection is considered meaningful in traditional Jewish theology, as it reinforces
the world creation narrative of the Old Testament wherein man is created from the
dust of the ground. In other words, Adam is "of the earth", and specifically "of red earth", or
red clay. Outside of the theological context, we can also reasonably interpret that the earth is
red because it is covered in blood, an image very apt for the theme of Holy Wood.
While the first section of the album- In The Shadow- could be thought of as an exposition for the
setting of the story, and the second section, The Androgyn, an exposition about Adam- his thoughts
and feelings about being an outsider, this third section is more about the here and now of coping
with being an "insider". You made the effort to step into society, try to participate, only to be
greeted by terrible disillusionment. The grass isn't greener on that side; it's actually just as
bad, if not worse, as the place you came from, and not everyone can deal with it in a healthy
manner. Some are driven to shoot up their school (The Nobodies), someone else may be driven to
kill a celebrity (Lamb of God), and Adam just becomes incredibly cynical, giving up on caring in
the face of an almost Kafkaesque levels of societal absurdity.
The Nobodies
This is the song that speaks in the most direct way about the Columbine massacre, and how it was treated by the media.
Lyrics | Commentary |
---|---|
Today I am dirty and I want to be pretty Tomorrow, I know that I'm just dirt | A straightforward way to understand this verse is that it's about feeling unworthy, and
thinking this will never change. A more ominous way to understand this verse is by employing a double meaning to the word dirty, where in the first line it means "bad" or "unworthy", and in the third line it implies being one with the earth, or in other words- dead and buried. Finally, some people associate the word choice in this verse with a quote from Carl Panzram, although I'm not aware of any interview in which Manson admitted the connection. Panzram was a serial criminal who truly hated life and devoted all of his effort to take vengeance on the world. His list of crimes includes murder, rape, arson, and robbery, and at some point, he even contemplated ways to provoke a war between the United States and Britain. While he was in prison, he made friends with a physician who encouraged him to write his autobiography, and he did. It's called Panzram, and one passage from it is theorized to inspire this song's lyrics: So if I succeed in my effort at suicide tonight then this will sure be the last I'll ever say or write on this earth. The choice is mine and I fully realize just what I am doing. I would like to have it known just why I do this. I had no choice about coming into this world and nearly all of my 38 years in it I have had very little to say or do about how I should live my life. People have driven me into doing everything I have ever done. Now the time has come when I refuse to be driven any further. Tonight I die and tomorrow I go to the grave farther than that no man can drive me I am sure glad to leave this lousy world and the lousier people that live in it. But of all the lousy people in this world I believe that I am the lousiest of them all. Today I am dirty but tomorrow I'll be just DIRT. |
We are the nobodies we wanna be somebodies when we're dead, they'll know just who we are | There is a theory that the word choice in this chorus is inspired by Mark David Chapman, the
man who murdered John Lennon. He told the authorities that:"I was an acute nobody. I had to usurp someone else's importance, someone else's success. I was 'Mr. Nobody' until I killed the biggest Somebody on earth." Unlike the Panzram theory, this one is considerably more substantiated, since Manson mentions Mark David explicitly in the song Lamb of God. However, I'm still not aware of any official word on the matter. |
Yesterday I was dirty wanted to be pretty I know now that I'm forever dirt We are the nobodies we wanna be somebodies when we're dead, they'll know just who we are | |
Some children died the other day we fed machines and then we prayed puked up and down in morbid faith you should have seen the ratings that day... | This part speaks of the aftermath of the shooting, and how society reacted to it. How the
media was all over the story (the machines being fed are news cameras), and how everybody
tried to put the "god band aid" on the event, saying "comforting" things such as "they're with
god now", which is way more morbid than it is comforting if you think about it. Everybody tuned in to watch the news, with the rating being as high as the most popular entertainment events like the super bowl, or the finale of a popular TV series. This is why the merchandise for the era included a T-shirt that said: Is adult entertainment killing our children? Or is killing children entertains our adults? |
The Death Song
This is a song about disillusionment with how you've been told to live your life, the realization that the grass isn't greener on the other side, that there's no "greener" place nor future to aim for, and the nihilistic attitude it inspires.
In an interview with Metal Edge magazine, Manson said that this song is "very sarcastic and nihilistic. It's like 'we have no future, and we don't give a fuck'".
Samples
The song ends with a choir singing "(You reign now) in heaven with Jesus our King" from "Immaculate Mary - Lourdes Hymn".
Lyrics | Commentary |
---|---|
We're on a bullet and we're headed straight into god even he'd like to end it too | The song opens with a blatant statement of nihilism: we're going to kill God, and even he is fed up with this life. |
we take a pill, get a face buy our ticket and we hope that heaven's true | We live a life centered around getting into a heaven that we don't even know for sure if it
exists. "Take a pill" is the casual action of using over the counter drugs, as opposed to the act of curing a disease. When you're trying to cure a disease, you don't just "take a pill", you take an entire regimen of drugs. "Take a pill" is what you do when you have a headache or allergies that you need to get rid of. It's what you do when you don't care about fixing the cause of the symptoms, but instead are content with just making the symptoms go away. This is apt for a society that focuses on the afterlife. There's no point in fixing anything if it's just going to be abandoned for another life. "Get a face" is from the phrase "put my face on", which means apply makeup. We do this in preparation for the big event of transitioning to the afterlife. "Buy our ticket" is from the phrase "a ticket to heaven". It's supposed to be earned through acceptance of Jesus Christ, and repentance for sin, but Manson describes it as "purchasing" a ticket, which is a cynical interpretation, but not an unreasonable one. If someone tells you that there's a reward for good deeds, you might do the deeds for the reward rather than desire to be good. In that sense, it's as morally vacuous as just purchasing the ticket with money. |
I saw a cop beat a priest on the TV and they know they killed our heroes too | A naïve person might think of public figures like a cop or a priest as people you can look up to, but then you see them fight each other and realize they're just as uncivilized as anybody else. They kill our heroes in the sense that they ruin the image of them that we've been holding on to. |
We sing the death song kids because we've got no future and we want to be just like you and we want to be just like you Let's sing the death song kids | The chorus is best explained with the lyrics at the end of the song: "We were the world, now
we got no future". "We were the world", and "we sing the death song kids", suggests to me that "we were the world" is based on the famous USA For Africa song We Are The World, whose chorus includes the lyrics "We are the world, we are the children". It's a song that epitomizes the JFK quote that "Children are the world's most valuable resource and its best hope for the future." But now, these little treasures of potential and hope grew up to be nobodies with no hope for the future, so they have nothing else to do but sing the death song, and wish they still had some value (want to be just like you, kids who are the world). |
we light a candle on an earth we made into hell and pretend that we're in heaven each time we do we get the blind man's ticket and we know that nothing's true | we light a candle on an earth Candle lighting is part of Christian ceremony, for example during prayer. Once again religion is described as being a substitute for any real improvement, a means for burying your head in the sand to ignore the hell you are in. each time we do we get The blind man could be a reference to the blind man whom Jesus cured of blindness. In the Gospel of John 9:1-12, Jesus saw a man who was blind since birth, and his disciples asked Jesus: "Rabbi, who sinned, this man or his parents, that he was born blind?" Jesus' reply was: "Neither this man nor his parents sinned ... but this happened so that the works of God might be displayed in him". He then proceeded to cure the man of blindness. Essentially, the blind man was exploited by God. Made to suffer for no fault of his own just so that he could be used by Jesus to strengthen his following. Each time we choose to live in hell to keep trying to earn our ticket into heaven, we get the same lousy deal as the blind man got in the gospel, suffering needlessly for a benefit we could've had from the start. It's enough to make one question everything (know that nothing's true), because it goes against everything that we've been told about how sin works; You can be punished for doing nothing, and accepting the way of Christ does not save us from living in hell. |
I saw priest kill a cop on the TV and I know now they're our heroes too | If these are our heroes, God help us. |
We sing the death song kids because we've got no future and we want to be just like you and we want to be just like you | |
we write our prayers on a little bomb kiss it on the face and send it to god | If there's no future and the present is hell, why not try to destroy it all? |
We sing the death song kids because we've got no future and we want to be just like you and we want to be just like you We were the world but we've got no future and we want to be just like you we want to be just like you. |
Lamb of God
Lamb of God is a title for Jesus Christ. It appears in the Gospel of John 1:29, where John the Baptist sees Jesus and says:
Behold the Lamb of God who takes away the sin of the world.
The term originates from the ancient practice of sacrificing lambs to God as an act of worship, and as an act of atonement for sin. Jesus is the lamb of God because God sent him to be sacrificed to cleanse the world of sin.
Lyrics | Commentary |
---|---|
There was Christ in the metal shell there was blood on the pavement The camera will make you god That's how Jack became sainted | We're at the scene of an assassination. Someone was shot with a gun. In the violence-worshipping
Holy Wood it is a holy event, hence the bullet is imbued by the spirit of Christ. Once again Manson brings up the idea that dying on TV makes you so culturally noteworthy that you almost turn into a divine figure, and once again brings up the example of JFK (Jack) as one who was sainted by dying on TV. |
If you die when there's no one watching Then your ratings drop and you're forgotten But if they kill you on their TV You're a martyr and a lamb of god Nothing's going to change Nothing's going to change the world | |
There was Lennon in the happy gun There were words on the pavement We were looking for the lamb of god We were looking for Mark David | There was Lennon in the happy gun John Lennon, of The Beatles fame, was a very idealistic man. Activism was a big part of both his life and his music, hence he is one of those idealistic revolutionaries of the previous generation that Manson contrasts against the modern Columbine generation. When the lyrics say that the gun was imbued with the spirit of Lennon, it means it's imbued with the spirit of revolution. The "happy gun" is a reference to The Beatles song Happiness Is A Warm Gun. A warm gun is a gun that was just shot, so the happy gun would be a gun that was just shot, which is appropriate for the assassination scene described in the song. Lennon was assassinated by Mark David, a fan of The Beatles who was angry at Lennon for a variety of things: Lennon's anti-religious stance, his renouncement of The Beatles, and the hypocrisy of Lennon living a wealthy lifestyle while simultaneously singing "imagine there's no possessions". In that sense, Mark David's use of firearms was to make a point, though in retrospect, he also admitted that he felt like a nobody and wanted to become famous. There were words on the pavement The pavement represents the location in which the assassination took place, and the words could simply be the ensuing commotion. It could also refer to the details of the assassination event, because right after Mark shot Lennon, the bleeding Lennon had a verbal exchange with the doorman of the Dakota building, and then the doorman had a verbal exchange with Mark David, who remained in the crime scene to wait for the police to take him. Finally, the words could be a reference to the book Catcher In The Rye, which Mark was reading while waiting for the cops. It's a book that had a lot of personal significance for Mark, so much so that after he was arrested, he told the police that "I'm sure the big part of me is Holden Caulfield, who is the main person in the book. The small part of me must be the Devil." We were looking for the lamb of god To me, this is written from the point of view of the officers who arrived at the crime scene. They came looking for the lamb of God and for Mark David in the sense that they came there looking for the ones involved. |
If you die when there's no one watching Then your ratings drop and you're forgotten But if they kill you on their TV You're a martyr and a lamb of god | |
Nothing's going to change the world Nothing's going to change Nothing's going to change the world Nothing's going to change The world | In an interview for MTV, Manson confirmed this to be a reference to the Beatles song
Across The Universe, whose lyrics were written by Lennon and contained the line
"Nothing's gonna change my world".Mark David Chapman came along and proved him very wrong. That was always something growing up that was very sad and tragic to me, a song that I always identified with. On Manson's song the line is changed to the more general "nothing's going to change the world", which can be taken as a desperate pessimism that the world will continue to be violent and horrible, or, if you want to get particularly playful with it, you can interpret "Nothing" as being a person- a nobody- who's going to change the world by depriving it of a musical genius. |
It took three days for him to die The born again could buy the serial rights Lamb of god have mercy on us Lamb of god won't you grant us | After Jesus died, his body lay in a tomb for three days before he was resurrected. In this
verse, Manson is saying that the death itself took three days, which isn't congruent with
neither Lennon (who was pronounced dead on arrival to the hospital) nor Jesus (who only
lasted 6 hours on the cross), but there's no better association to be made in a song that
calls itself Lamb of God, so we have to take this as a bit of creative license. The Born Again are those who have converted to Christianity. It refers to the spiritual rebirth that comes with accepting Jesus as the lord and savior. Buying the serial rights to the lamb's death represents the commercialization of his martyrdom. Indeed, Manson once described the crucifix as "the most successful piece of merchandise ever created". Lamb of god have mercy on us These lines are taken from the Agnus Dei, a prayer that honors the Lamb of God: Lamb of God, who takes away the sins of the world, have mercy on us. |
Nothing's going to change the world Nothing's going to change Nothing's going to change the world Nothing's going to change The world If you die when there's no one watching Then your ratings drop and you're forgotten But if they kill you on their TV You're a martyr and a lamb of god Nothing's going to change the world |
Born Again
A born again is someone who converts to Christianity. The term represents the spiritual rebirth that happens when one accepts Jesus Christ as the lord and savior. Thus, the term can be seen as the act of joining a group, and attempting to fit in by accepting their values. In this song, Manson uses the term as a metaphor for an artist selling out.
Lyrics | Commentary |
---|---|
Do you or don't you want this to be your song? It doesn't take a rebel to sing along. This art is weak in its pretty, pretty frame and I am a monkey with a misspelled name | This verse is written from the POV of a musical artist that has sold out, and is somewhat
resentful of that fact, because he'd rather make art that causes meaningful change. First, he says that it doesn't take a rebel to do the same thing that an entire crowd of fans does (enjoy a song). It means there's a catch-22 problem with trying to be rebellious through art. If the artist is insignificant, their rebellion isn't meaningful to the world, but if the artist becomes big enough to make an impact, liking them ceases to be an act of rebellion, and instead becomes an act of following the crowd. In other words, it's almost unavoidable for a rebellion to "sell out" once it becomes mainstream enough. This art is weak in its pretty, pretty frame With mainstream commercialization, the production values around the art certainly increase (the pretty frame), but the art itself loses its potency. and I am a monkey with a misspelled name There are many artists who misspell their name on purpose. Examples include: The Beatles, Spiral Starecase, Def Leppard, Led Zeppelin, Mötley Crüe, The Byrds, The Black Crowes, Stryper, Megadeth, The Monkees, Gorillaz, Lynyrd Skynyrd, Limp Bizkit, KoRn, Linkin Park, Rammstein, Split Enz, The Kovenant, Bon Jovi, The Cyrkle, Jackyl, Nu Shooz, The Insyderz Kutless, Phish, Blessid Union of Souls, Chvrches Trapt, Kool and the Gang, The Weeknd, Ludacris Paramore, Wrabit. So, this might be a self-deprecating way of saying "and I'm just another monkey, just like any one of those other artists". |
"I'll put down your disco and take you heart away" I'll be born again | This is a Charles Manson quote from an interview with Charlie Rose. Charles was asked what
he would say if he could write a song right now. His answer was: "you better bow down disco,
I'm going to take your heart away". Disco was once incredibly popular, so the sentiment here is "I'll become the new mainstream". |
I'm someone else I'm someone new I'm someone stupid just like you | After going through the transformation of rebirth/selling-out, he becomes someone new, as stupid as everybody else is. |
do you or don't you want to take this hit? Does it make you feel like you're a part of "it." | The "hit" he asks about is a "hit song". |
"I'll put down your disco and take your heart away" I am born again I'm someone else I'm someone new I'm someone stupid just like you | |
the valley of the dolls is the valley of the dead | The Valley of The Dolls is a novel by Jacqueline Susann, which was also made into a movie. It tells the story of 3 women who try to forge a career in the entertainment industry, and each one eventually descends to barbiturate addiction. Its use here is probably to represent Hollywood, the capital of the entertainment industry, which also includes the music industry. This lyric says it's not actually a hospitable environment for artists, but rather where art goes to die. |
I'm someone else I'm someone new I'm someone stupid just like you I'll be born again... |
Burning Flag
A burning flag is a metaphor for a nation in turmoil. A great deal of the song describes how fucked up things have become, and the rest of the lyrics are about being a misfit in such an environment.
Lyrics | Commentary |
---|---|
They wanna sell it Buy it up Dumb it down A good god is hard to find | The media is always on the quest for their next big product, but usually they aren't so lucky to find something that's already commercialized of its own volition, so most of the time they buy things and dumb them down (essentially ruining them) in order to sculpt them into a commercial product. |
I'll join the crowd That wants to see me dead Right now I feel I belong for the first time | What does selling out means for someone who is a rebel, and therefore a controversial figure?
Doesn't that mean joining the same mainstream that hates him? In an interview with MTV, Manson commented on how strange it felt for him to be part of the mainstream: Well, the line that precedes that, actually, is, "I joined the crowd that wants to see me dead, right now I belong for the first time." So in that sense, yeah, I feel like I belong to a part of culture that doesn't really like me, and it's a strange feeling. You know, like finding myself on "TRL," I feel very inappropriate. So in that sense I belong in my own special way, like a venereal disease. |
Multiply your death Divide by sex Add up the violence and what do you get? | The formula for commercial success? |
We are all just stars and we're waiting We are all just scarred and we're hating We are all just stars on your burning flag | "Stars on your burning flag" implies that the burning flag is the flag of the United States. No surprises here given that Manson is an American artist. The stars are waiting for their 15 minutes of fame, and they're motivated by hate and trauma, because everything about this world is fucked. They're aiming to be the stars in a disaster. |
You point the gun at me And hope it'll go away If god was alive He would hate you anyway | You point the gun at me The mainstream thinks that by taking him down, they'll feel better about whatever inner trauma he is triggering inside them. A good example of this pattern is Mark David, who assassinated John Lennon because he felt like a nobody and wanted that to change. If god was alive But it's not going to work, because it won't change the fact that you are wretched anyway. Indeed, Mark David did not get the relief he hoped for from killing John Lennon. He was still miserable and ended up regretting his actions. |
My right wing is flapping My left one is gray Let's hear it for the kids but Nothing they say They gyrate and g-rate on election day We got our ABC and our F-U-C-K | My right wing is flapping Right wing and left wing refer to the conservative and liberal political orientations, respectively. While it's perfectly normal for a wing to be flapping, I think the implication is more like "flailing around helplessly", because it doesn't seem like the imagery is describing normal flight where both wings are engaged. The left wing is grey, meaning old. Let's hear it for the kids but Everybody claims to be trying to help the children, but in practice they don't actually do anything. They'll rally everybody up for the chant, but then the chant doesn't come. They gyrate and g-rate on election day "Gyrate" implies something pornographic, like pole dancing. A G rating is the "general audience - all ages permitted" rating. In other words, pretty much the opposite of pornographic entertainment. "They" try to appeal to everybody, and end up diluting their message to nothing, because if your message is both a thing and its opposite, then you're not really saying anything. The second line is the same idea of being both adult and family friendly. ABC is the alphabet song that kids learn, and FUCK is the adult version. Or, ABC could be ABC News, and FUCK could be politics in general. |
Multiply your death Divide by sex Add up the violence and what do you get? We are all just stars and we're waiting We are all just scarred and we're hating We are all just stars on your burning flag You point the gun at me And hope it'll go away If god was alive He would hate you anyway We are all just stars and we're waiting We are all just scarred and we're hating We are all just stars on your burning flag Stars on your burning flag |
M: The Fallen
This is the part of the story where everything ends badly for our protagonist. The way in which I think the songs connect with one another, is that:
- The world creates a rift between Adam and his lover, causing him to lose the only good thing in his life. At first, he simply wants to kill himself. But then...
- He sees a girl committing suicide on TV. Maybe this girl is his lover, maybe it's just some random girl. Adam is haunted by this image and decides that a world where something like this is celebrated deserves to be punished. His plan turns to a killing spree.
- He prepares to assassinate the president.
- He goes on a killing spree.
- Having evaded the police long enough to reach home, Adam knows there's nowhere left to run, and he commits suicide.
Coma Black: a) Eden Eye, b) The Apple of Discord
Manson's previous album Mechanical Animals had a song called Coma White. Naturally, this gives rise to a contrast with Coma Black, though the nature and the extent of the contrast is not obvious. There's no official information about this song that I'm aware of that can shed some clear light on how much of it ties in with Coma White, and in what way, and how much of it is meant to stand on its own, and the song is abstract enough that you could interpret it either way. You could interpret it as a work of Holy Woodian fiction that bears only superficial similarities to the concept of the original song, but it is also possible to interpret it as something that is rooted deeply in the original concept of Coma White, and that's the direction that I lean to, since I think that the name of the song is too specific to not be meaningful.
Coma White was inspired by Manson's fiancé Rose McGowan. Rose had a long series of abusive experiences in Hollywood that left her emotionally wounded, and Coma White was essentially about that. Manson and Rose broke up following the Columbine fiasco, in late 2000, with Rose implying that it was due to his drug use. Since the Columbine incident was undoubtedly a stressful period for Manson, it wouldn't surprise me if it was a contributing factor which intensified Manson's drug use beyond what Rose was able to tolerate. So, one tempting interpretation is that Coma Black was inspired by Manson losing Rose in the midst of a difficult period of his life. The spoken words that open the song, which aren't part of the official lyrics, seem to fit with this concept:
A loved one laid his head in her lap
Red roses fell to the floor
And the world stood still.
Rose co-starred with Manson in the music video for Coma White, where they played Jackie Onassis and JFK, respectively. The video recreated the JFK assassination, which looked like this:
Wounded by the world (in this case Columbine), Manson laid his head in her lap for comfort. Then, Rose slipped away from him (roses fell to the floor), and life as he knew it stopped (the world stood still).
Lyrics | Commentary |
---|---|
Eden Eye | |
My mouth was a crib, and it was growing lies I didn't know what love was on that day my heart's a tiny blood clot I picked at it it never heals it never goes away | The opening scene takes us to "that day", the day of the breakup, and the heartache that ensued. He had only lies with which to try and stop the inevitable from happening, because the reality of the situation (the truth of the situation) was not in his favor. |
I burned all the good things in The Eden Eye we were too dumb to run too dead to die | The idiom "in someone's eyes" means "in someone's opinion". In other words, he burned all
the things that Eden sees as good. In the chorus, he laments that someone took his angel
away, and since this is a song about the loss of a relationship, the angel is his lover (in
our case Rose). If his lover is an angel, a creature of Eden, her eyes have the perspective
of Eden. In other words, through self-destructive behavior, he burned all the good things
she saw in him and/or their relationship. This was a tragedy in the making that the two of them did not have the wisdom to avoid (too dumb to run away from), and one they could not detect in time (too dead to die) because they were both broken people (dead), and when you're broken, dysfunction feels normal. If they weren't so broken (dead), they would've felt the destructive power of the dysfunction immediately (would've been able to die from the fire), which would've alerted them to the destructive nature of the situation before it was too late. |
This was never my world you took the angel away I'd kill myself to make everybody pay | He is an outsider, who never fit in. He had one precious thing in his life, his angel, and they- meaning the world- took her away from him. This could represent the idea that if Columbine didn't happen, they wouldn't have had this interpersonal crisis that broke them up. In that sense, Columbine took Rose away from him. |
I would have told her then she was the only thing I could love in this dying world but the simple word "love" itself already died and went away This was never my world you took the angel away I'd kill myself to make everybody pay I burned all the good things in The Eden Eye we were too dumb to run too dead to die | |
Apple Of Discord | |
Her heart's a bloodstained egg we didn't handle with care it's broken and bleeding and we can never repair | The term "apple of discord" means "a thing that leads to a big dispute". It comes from the
Greek Mythology story Judgment of Paris. In the story, Eris the goddess of
strife does not get invited to the wedding of Peleus and Thetis. As revenge, she brings a
golden apple inscribed "to the fairest one" and throws it into the wedding, which causes a
dispute between Hera, Athena, and Aphrodite over who should get the apple. The dispute
eventually leads to the Trojan War. In this verse, the subject of the lyrics switches to "Her", as opposed to "Him" in the previous section. Describing her heart as a bleeding egg, that is irreparably broken, and wasn't taken care of, is very appropriate for what we know about Rose's difficult history. By calling this section the "apple of discord", Manson seems to be saying that the crux of their dispute, was the fact that Rose was too broken to have the strength to be there for him in his darkest hour. The lyrics in this section bear some resemblance to the poem Words by Anne Sexton: Yet often they fail me. |
Valentine's Day
Valentine's Day is the holiday of love. In this case, the love that's being celebrated is the Holy Woodian love of death, so every joyous occasion in which someone dies is like Valentine's Day.
It's interesting to note that the first time that the Zapruder Film was shown in full on TV was February 14, 1969, which was Valentine's Day in the year Manson was born, so this could be what inspired the concept of the song.
Lyrics | Commentary |
---|---|
She was the color of T.V. Her mouth curled under like a metal snake Although Holy Wood was sad They'd remember this as Valentine's Day | She was the color of T.V. Color makes the image on the TV lively and beautiful. This is a way of saying that she herself was beautiful, and everybody who watched her on TV fell in love. Her mouth curled under like a metal snake This is a very confusing line. I think that the way to interpret it is this: "Metal snake" isn't describing her mouth. A mouth is nothing like a metal snake. It must be describing something else, a thing that isn't mentioned explicitly, but is implied. There's an implication in the verse that she died. One thing that could kill her, is made of metal, and is tube shaped like a snake, is the barrel of a gun. So, the full version of this lyric would be: "Her mouth curled under the barrel of the gun, which was like a metal snake". She put the gun in her mouth and shot herself on TV. Although Holy Wood was sad Although Holy Wood was sad for her death, it was also in-love with her dying image, hence it was like Valentine's Day. |
Flies are waiting In the Shadow of the Valley of Death They slit our wrists and send us to heaven The first flower after the flood | Flies are waiting Flies are attracted to corpses. The denizens of Holy Wood are like flies waiting for their next corpse. They slit our wrists and send us to heaven ...to be gods. The first flower after the flood In the biblical story of the flood, Noah got a sign that the waters were receding when the bird he sent to scout for land returned with an olive branch. This olive branch signified a new beginning (and also the end of the catastrophe). Here we have a similar idea, a symbol of a new beginning, but with a flower instead of an olive branch. Flowers signify romance, so this represents the beginning of a new romance with the gods they just inaugurated in the previous line. |
I saw that pregnant girl today She didn't know that it was dead inside Even though it was alive Some of us are really born to die | This verse describes a stillbirth situation. The fetus dies in the womb, but it continues to
be on the mother's life support until the moment of birth. The crux of this verse is the
final line, which can be a metaphor for the fact that for some people, the only meaningful
achievement in their life will be how they die. This part of the song seems less related to the theme of Valentine's Day, but we can tie it in with the observation that a baby is supposed to be the fruit of two people's love, and that babies themselves are the subjects of their parents' love. The mother would instinctively love her (metaphorically) stillborn baby, and the denizens of Holy Wood would love that baby once it achieves its destiny of dying. |
Flies are waiting In the Shadow of the Valley of Death They slit our wrists and send us to heaven The first flower after the flood In the Shadow of the Valley of Death |
The Fall of Adam
The fall of Adam is a term in Christianity that refers to the transition of the first man and woman from a state of innocent obedience to God to a state of guilty disobedience. In the bible it happens when Adam and Eve eat from the tree of knowledge. On Holy Wood, it happens when an outcast finally makes the decision to open fire at the world that wronged him.
Lyrics | Commentary |
---|---|
The Abraham Lincoln town cars arrive To dispose of our king and queen They orchestrated dramatic new scenes for Celebritarian™ needs | When JFK died, the car he was riding in was the Lincoln Continental, which in 1981 was
renamed to Lincoln Town Car. The Lincoln Motor Company, who is the manufacturer of these
cars, is indeed named after Abraham Lincoln. In the scene described by this verse we see yet another presidential motorcade, one that will end with yet another killing of the king. The song claims these events were orchestrated, which could be an allusion to the conspiracy theories about JFK's assassination. These theories allege that Oswald wasn't acting alone, and that the CIA and/or KGB and/or Mafia and/or Fidel Castro and/or Lyndon Johnson were involved. Either way, from the title of the song, we can assume that it's Adam who's holding the rifle this time. The notes in the album booklet state that: "Celebritarian™ used by permission", creating the impression that it is a third-party organization. In actuality, the Celebritarian Corporation was Manson's own invention, a name he has given to a self-proclaimed art movement. It was a pet project of Manson that never materialized the grand potential that Manson envisioned for it. It is clear from interviews that touched on the subject that Manson wanted it to be a side project of ultimate artistic freedom where he would be free to do things outside of music, and collaborate freely with other artists. In practice, very little Celebritarian projects actually materialized, and no cohesive notion of what the movement stands for was ever articulated. The most in-depth description of the concept was given by Manson in a 2005 interview with the now defunct mansonusa.com fansite, where Manson said it could mean just about anything, but also tied it into the themes of Holy Wood: Celebritarianism, I think, is best defined by whoever is interested in it. That doesn't mean that it has no meaning, or no universal meaning. It just means that people who don't understand what it is aren't going to understand it if they're explained it. Although I don't think there's any wrong way to understand it, either. |
When one world ends Something else begins But without a scream Just a whisper because we just Start it over again... | This section describes what happens when someone dies.When one world ends There is a famous Jewish saying by Hillel The Elder that "Whosoever destroys one soul, it is as though he had destroyed the entire world. And whosoever saves a life, it is as though he had saved the entire world", and I think this is the right way to interpret these two lines in light of the themes of death and resurrection that are invoked by subsequent lines. When one person dies, his soul is resurrected, and a new life begins. The idea that a person is a world is also present in the Jacob's Ladder diagram that appears in the album artwork. It's a diagram that consists of 4 sections that represent 4 "worlds", and there's a 5th implicit world which is Adam Kadmon himself. For more information, see the section about Jacob's Ladder under artwork. But without a scream This lyric has a conceptual similarity to T. S. Eliot's famous poem The Hollow Men, which ends with the lines: This is the way the world ends These two lines are some of the most quoted lines of 20th century poetry for the way they capture anticlimactic irony so perfectly. Their canonical meaning, however, is by no means a settled matter, though informed scholarly analysis certainly exists. Within that scholarly analysis, a connection with the themes of Holy Wood emerges: Eliot's poem speaks about the fate of Hollow Men, the men who were too insignificant in life to qualify for neither Heaven nor Hell in the afterlife. We can think of them as the nobodies. In A Student's Guide to the Selected Poems of T.S. Eliot, B. C. Southam connects the inspiration for these two lines to a poem about an execution: Eliot may have had in mind two lines from Danny Deever (1892) by Rudyard Kipling, a poem he knew by heart at the age of ten. Deever, a British soldier, is executed in front of his regiment for killing another comrade: While Deever's execution is done by hanging, Eliot's version is a better fit for a gunshot. A gunshot is certainly a bang, but the moment of finality happens in the whimper that follows. Per Manson's version, the last sound our headshot president is going to make isn't going to be a scream, but something far more feeble, perhaps nothing more than a final exhalation. Manson's verse also speaks of a recurrence (we start it over again). What type of recurrence? One possibility is reincarnation. When one life ends, the soul starts its life journey all over again, and a new life begins. This interpretation ties in with Southam's analysis of Eliot's famous two lines: The 'whimper' may also combine an allusive reference to Dante, suggesting the cry of a baby, the new-born leaving one world to enter another |
Do you love your guns? Your god and your government? Let me hear you (hey) Do you love your guns and god and your government? (hey) Do you love your guns and your government and your god? Let me hear you (hey) Your mother? And your father? And your baby? Goddamn it let me hear you (hey) Do you love your guns? I want your mothers and your fathers To hear you say it (hey) I'd like to single one of you motherfuckers Let me hear it from you (hey) Do you love your guns? And your god and your government? (hey) I wanna hear it from everyone I wanna hear you say you want a gun Let me hear it (hey) | This section sounds like a president addressing a rally from a podium, promoting the same violent message we heard previously in The Love Song. And now we wait for the gunshot... |
King Kill 33°
King-Kill/33: Masonic Symbolism in the Assassination of John F. Kennedy is a conspiratorial essay written by James Shelby Downard, originally published in the first edition of the book Apocalyptic Culture. Shelby was a conspiracy theorist who focused on analyzing occult symbolism and synchronicity of historic events, and in King Kill 33 he advances a theory that it was the Freemasons who orchestrated the assassination of JFK to perform a ritual called the Killing of The King. The number 33 refers to the highest degree in the Scottish rite of Masonry.
This song is the angry manifest of someone who felt so mistreated by society that they decided to take vengeance upon the world. The statements made in the lyrics would not look out of place in the diaries of the Columbine shooters. In the context of the story that is told in the album, this would be the song in which Adam goes on a shooting spree.
Lyrics | Commentary |
---|---|
Is this what you wanted? This is what you get. Turned all your lives into this shit. You never accepted or treated me fair Blame me for what I believe and I wear. You fucked yourselves and you Raised these sheep The blue and the withered seeds you will reap. You never gave me a chance to be me Or even a fucking chance just to be. But I have to show you that you played a role And I will destroy you with one simple hole. The world that hates me has taken its toll But now I have finally taken control. You wanted so bad to make me this thing And I want you now to just kill the king... | Most of this is self-explanatory. The one line that is a bit confused is the one at the end
of this segment:And I want you now to just kill the king... Presumably the speaker is on a killing spree and wants everybody to die. Why would he want "them" to kill the president? I think the intended meaning is "and I want you now to do to me what you did to Kennedy". In other words, "kill me so that I will be immortalized". It's a desire to go out in a blaze of glory. |
And I am not sorry, and I am not sorry This is what you deserve King Kill 33 |
Count To Six And Die (The Vacuum of Infinite Space Encompassing)
The name "Count To Six And Die" is a reference to the revolver pistol, a pistol that has a 6 bullet cylinder. In the Russian Roulette game, only one chamber in the cylinder is loaded with a bullet. The participants take turn firing the pistol at their own head until one of them ends up shooting the bullet at their head.
The subtitle "The Vacuum of Infinite Space Encompassing" is a reference to a diagram that appeared in an 1879 illustrated edition of Milton's Paradise Lost.
This diagram is a map of the universe according to Milton's Paradise Lost, as interpreted by Homer B. Sprague. The black half circle at the top is Heaven, or The Empyrean, AKA the kingdom of God. The sphere with the many circles (our starry universe) is the kingdom of man, the "new world" that God created, suspended from the Heaven by a golden chain (not depicted here). At the very bottom is hell, the place Satan and his angels fall to after being defeated by the army of God. In between hell and the Empyrean is the realm of chaos and night, a vast expanse of untamed potential that was never shaped by God into anything concrete.
According to this diagram, there's a space of ultimate nothingness outside of the universe created by God, a place so empty it lacks even the spirit of God. In Count To Six And Die, it represents the nothingness that your consciousness disappears into when you die.
The song begins with the sound of a door shutting, followed by silence, followed by music that retains the feeling of a quiet empty space. The protagonist of our story managed to escape somewhere private after the killing spree in the previous song, but he knows that the world is on his heels, and judgment is just a few steps behind him. It is now or never. Adam commits suicide.
Lyrics | Commentary |
---|---|
She's got her eyes open wide She's got the dirt and spit of the world She's got her mouth on the metal The lips of a scared little girl | We see a girl with the barrel of a gun in her mouth. Either this is a throwback to the girl
with a gun in her mouth from the song Valentine's Day, or this is an entirely unrelated
character who came out of nowhere without any prior introduction, and just happens to cover
the same ground as the girl from Valentine's Day. Personally, I think the first option is
more reasonable. Why is this girl in the song? Because Adam is still haunted by her death, especially if she is indeed Coma, in which case their dual death is a romantic tragedy. |
I've got an angel in the lobby He's waiting to put me in line I won't ask forgiveness My faith has gone dry | We switch to first person. This is Adam speaking. God sent an angel after Adam to catch and punish him. It's already in the lobby, and there's nowhere left for Adam to run. The only way out is through that lobby. Adam is resigned to the situation. He's not going to fight for his soul, for he no longer believes that redemption is possible (his faith has gone dry). |
She's got her Christian prescriptures And death has crawled in her ear Like elevator music of songs that She shouldn't hear | Back to the girl.She's got her Christian prescriptures Prescriptures = prescriptions + scriptures This is how we know that the image of her with a gun in her mouth represents her shooting herself, and not her being shot by somebody else. The girl was taught death by Christianity, and the idea of killing herself slowly grew in her mind. |
And it spins around- 1,2,3 And we all lay down- 4,5,6 Some do it fast And some do it better in smaller amounts | And we all lay down We all die. Notice that we are back in 1st person ('We' is first person), so we are back to Adam's perspective. Some do it fast Some of us die quickly (for example, by suicide). Others die of old age: they kill themselves in tiny doses by edging each day closer to a fatal old age. Manson calls it the "better" way to kill yourself. Either way, we all kill ourselves in the end, regardless of the method. |
The song ends with the sound of the revolver being cocked and shot 5 times, each one a firing of an empty chamber. The gun cocks one last time, and the album ends. Not with a bang, but a whimper, because dead people don't hear the gunshot that killed them.
Artwork
Front
In an interview for Hotpress, Manson had this to say about the cover of the album:
It's a combination of my jawless face with the statue of Christ taken from a church. The image was supposed to suggest that something we've take for granted all our lives can be looked at as something violent and sexual as well. So religious people who indict entertainment as being violent, it's kind of ironic because Christ was the first celebrity and all entertainment comes from religion. And my jaw being removed is to represent the silencing of people with dangerous opinions.
--Marilyn Manson, Hotpress interview
Above Manson's head are the letters RI, and the letter omega. The omega represents "the end", based on the line from Revelation:
I am the alpha and the omega, the beginning and the end.
--Revelation 21:6
The letters RI are from the initialism INRI (Latin: Iesus Nazarenus, Rex Iudaeorum), which means "Jesus the Nazarene, King of the Jews" (John 19:19). At the very bottom, poking through the tears, is a page from JFK's autopsy report.
Back
The symbol Manson is resting his head on is the Sigillum Dei, the seal of God, AKA the Seal of Truth in John Dee's version. It is believed to allow a magician to possess the spirit of God, and become God among humans.
Booklet
The flower coming out of the head is inspired by an interpretation of William Blake's work. One of the images that appear in the album artwork is a diagram of the world cosmology according to Blake's poetry. The parts of the diagram that are relevant to this picture are:
"The Mundane Shell": represents the skull, which encloses the brain in which consciousness resides.
...and right underneath it:
"Iris as Allamanda": In Blake's work, Allamanda is the nervous system. However, Allamanda is also a flower.
So, underneath the skull is a flower, and when a bullet creates a hole in the skull, it allows the flower to grow out through the hole. For more information, see section Visionary Geography in William Blake's Poetry.
This image is also surrounded by some text, which is taken from JFK's autopsy report:
...as well as images depicting the evolution of man's skull from ape to modern man, which seem to be from Evolution by Ruth Moore.
Alchemy and Mysticism
Most of the alchemical images in the artwork appear in the book Alchemy & Mysticism by Alexander Roob. In fact, one of the alchemical images that appears in the artwork, the one with the words "The vacuum of infinite space encompassing all", has the same truncation of the word "all", as in Roob's book. It is therefore my belief that this book is the source and inspiration for the artwork.
The essence of God
Innermost text:
This Abyssal Nothing will introduce itself into - Something Viz into Nature; that is into
Properties: and through Nature into Glory & Majesty. This now is done
...the end of this text continues into two spirals:
Inner spiral:
by a Sharp, Harsh or Strong Desire, represented by this Gross and Dark Circling Line: Which
Desire is turning out, together with the Lubet (yet not mixed nor...
Outer spiral:
by a Soft, Meek or Tender Lubet, represented by this finer Circling Line: Which Lubet goes:
along with (but secretly and incomprehensibly to) the Desire through.
This illustration is taken from volume 2 of The Works of Jacob Behmen, a four-volume collection of Jakob Böhme's writings, compiled by William Law. Jakob Böhme was a German mystic whose work featured many alchemical references, as well as elements of Gnosticism and the Kabbalah. The illustration itself was done by another German mystic, Dionysius Andreas Freher, whose work focused primarily on Jakob Böhme's theories.
This illustration belongs to a sequence of thirteen illustrations that depict the story of creation, fall of Lucifer, fall of Adam, and then man's redemption through Jesus. It is the first illustration in the sequence, representing the pre-creation beginning, in which there was only God and nothing else. The spiraling nature of the illustration might be in reference to Böhme's idea that "The essence of God is like a wheel", and that God consists of two centrifugal and centripetal forces of will and unwill. This is why the inner spiral reads "which desire is turning out" (meaning outward), and the outer spiral reads "which lubet goes along with (but secretly to) the desire", meaning inward towards the inner circle.
The triangle represents the trinity. The Hebrew word in the middle of the triangle is called Tetragrammaton. It represents God's true name, and reads something like "Yahweh", although the true pronunciation is unknown, having been lost to time due to a Jewish superstition against uttering the name. It is considered to have immense power and is featured heavily in occult theories.
Further analysis from the author himself can be found in the appendix of the book where the image appears, which has a few pages "explaining" the 13 illustrations. For this illustration, the explanation reads as follows:
GOD, without all Nature and Creature. The Unformed Word in Trinity without all Nature. Vid. et N.B. Mysterium Magnum, iv. 3. The Eternal Unity, or Oneness, deeper than any Thought can reach. A and Ω; the Eternal Beginning and the Eternal End, the First and the Last. The greatest softness, Meekness, Stillness, Etc. Nothing and All. Eternal Liberty. Abyss, without Ground, Time, and Place. The Still Eternity. Mysterium Magnum without Nature. Chaos. The Mirror of Wonders, or Wonderful Eye of Eternity. The first Temperature, or Temperature of Nothingness; a Calm, Serene Habitation, but without all Luster and Glory. The Trinity Unmanifest, or rather, that Triune Unsearchable Being, which cannot be an Object of any created Understanding.
Egg astrology
This illustration comes from John Dee's Monas Hieroglyphica, a series of 24 theorems interpreting a symbol that he invented, called the Hieroglyphic Monad. The illustration appears in Theorem 18, which states that:
Theor. 18: From our twelfth and thirteenth Theorems it may be gathered that Celestial Astronomy is like a parent and master to INFERIOR [Astronomy].
[...]
As we were contemplating both the Theoretical and the Heavenly motions of that Celestial MESSENGER [Mercury], we were taught that the figure of an EGG might be applied to these COORDINATIONS. For it is well-known to Astronomers that he makes an OVAL-shaped Circuit on his course through the Aether.John Dee, Monas Hieroglyphica
Dee's theory is rooted in a school of thought that sees the fields of astronomy and alchemy as being derivatives of the same ancient principles, and therefore are really the same field of study, just coming at it from different directions. So, in theorem 18, when he speaks of "inferior astronomy", he actually refers to alchemy, the non-celestial astronomy.
The illustration shows the orbit of the planets, and how the varying radiuses of those orbits form the shape of an egg. From bottom to top, the symbols of the planets are: moon, "lunar" mercury, Venus, sun, Mars, Jupiter, and Saturn. If you are surprised by the fact that the Earth doesn't appear in the illustration, or confused by the strange order of the planets, the reason for that is because it is based on a geocentric world view which puts the Earth as the center of the universe. So, the Earth has no orbit, and would logically be located at the bottom tip of the egg.
The illustration has an inner circle, which divides the egg into inner and outer spaces, corresponding to the egg whites and the yolk. This divides the planets into "solar" planets, located in the yolk, and "lunar" planets, located in the white. The solar planets are planets whose symbols contain the sun symbol (a circle), and the lunar are the ones that contain the lunar symbol (the half circle). This separation is also demonstrated in the table below, with solar planets on the right, and lunar on the left:
It's interesting to note that Mercury appears as both a lunar and a solar planet, due to there being two versions of symbols that represent it. Of the solar version of Mercury, Dee wrote that:
In this progression Appears another Mercury, who indeed is the Uterine Brother of the first. This is clearly the fully complete Lunar and Solar Magic of the Elements, as the Hieroglyphic Messenger tells us most expressly, if only we fix our eyes upon him and lend him an attentive ear. He is (GOD WILLING) that most Famous Mercury of the Philosophers, the MICROCOSM and ADAM.
John Dee, Monas Hieroglyphica
All of this bears an interesting connection to the theme of the album. In Holy Wood, a mortal can ascend to the status of a god, much like how the symbol of Mercury, which represents Adam, has an inferior (lunar) and superior (solar) version.
He who wields the elements
These two images are from the 1676 alchemical work De Goude Leeuw of den aſijn der wijſen (The Gold Lion or The Vinegar Of The Wise) by Goossen van Vreeswyk. Goossen was a mining expert who had extensive knowledge of minerals, and his alchemical work was heavily focused on preparing extracts from animals, vegetables, and minerals.
Interpreting these two images within the context of Holy Wood requires some speculation since we have no idea where Manson got them from. However, it is my assumption that Manson probably did not delve into the alchemical technicalities of the images, and instead relied on third party interpretations. Had he actually studied the source material for these specific images, I do not believe it would've been very useful for him artistically, since based on partial reading of Goossen's book, I can report that it leans very heavily on the chemistry part of alchemy.
These two images are notable for the fact that they do not appear in Alchemy & Mysticism, unlike most of the alchemical images in this album. One place where they do appear is the book The Golden Game: Alchemical Engravings of the Seventeenth Century by Stanislas Klossowski De Rola, which provides the following analysis:
Image with the man:
Hercules as a child throttled the snakes sent by Juno to kill him. In alchemical symbolism Hercules is the Artist; the killing of the snakes is Fixation of the Volatile; and the flight of the Birds is Volatilization. The Four Elements are represented by Dolphin, Dragon, Bird and Salamander. As all the Philosophers maintain, he who can convert Earth into Water, the same Water into Air, the same Air into Fire, and the same Fire into Earth, shall know the entire process of the Philosopher's Stone.
Image without the man:
Opened by the martial sword, our Subject yields the Vitriol of the Wise.
Although the phrase "vitriol of the wise" sounds like it means "cruel and bitter criticism by the
wise" to a modern ear, it actually means something else alchemically. First of all, the word
"vitriol" used to mean "sulfuric acid", and second, if you look at the BLAD-WYSER appendix in
Goossen's book, which features an index of the topics discussed in the book and the page numbers
on which they appear, it becomes apparent that by "vitriol" he actually meant "vinegar":
The appendix says that "Vitriool of Acetum der Wyʃen" is referenced in page number 1. The
translation of this entry means "Vitriol or acetum of the wise", with acetum being an archaic
name for vinegar. The page number it points us to is the book cover, which contains the phrase
"or the vinegar of the wise".
We do not have information about whether Manson is familiar with Stanislas' book and the quotes it contains about the above images, but Stanislas' book does seem to have some level of fame, based on the fact that it is listed for ridiculous prices in the second hand market, and there is another image in the artwork of Holy Wood that doesn't appear in Alchemy & Mysticism, but does appear in The Golden Game (Saturn devouring his child). Therefore, it seems plausible that this book was also used by Manson as reference, though this is still within the realm of speculation. What is interesting to note is that the analysis provided by Stanislas can be easily tied to Holy Wood.
The idea that the conduit of transformation is an artist, is something that would undoubtedly appeal to Manson. And while it's unclear to me whether the man in the image is really supposed to be Hercules, he could just as easily be Adam, because Adam has a unique status in alchemy, often referred to as the first alchemist, so a depiction of him wielding the elements with skill is apt. The fact that the two pictures feature exactly the same alchemical symbols could be tied to the idea that you cannot change the world: Adam came and tried to wield the elements to transform the world, and when he was gone, the world was still the same. Finally, let's consider the commentary for the second image: opened by the martial sword, our Subject yields the Vitriol of the Wise. If you interpret "vitriol of the wise" in the modern sense of "cruel and bitter criticism by the wise", which is an easy mistake to make for anyone who isn't working with the source material, we get something that fits the story of Holy Wood really well: our martyr protagonist has insight about society, hence he is wise. He unleashes his cruel and bitter criticism on the world by violently sacrificing himself using the martial sword.
It is finished when seven are one
This image appears in The Paradoxical Emblems by Dionysius Andreas Freher, emblem number 139. The Paradoxical Emblems is a book of illustrations that represent concepts from the alchemical work of Jakob Böhme. Alchemy & Mysticism quotes Jakob Böhme in relation to this image:
It Is Finished When Seven Are One. "'The curse of God has entered the seven figures, so they are in conflict with one another.' Just as the human will was transformed 'into eternal sun, calm in God,' 'so in the Philosophical Work must all figures be transformed into one, into Sol. From seven must come one, and yet it remains in seven but in one desire, as every figure desires the others in love, so there is no longer any conflict.'
Jacob Böhme, De signatura rerum.
The concept of the seven becoming one is represented in the illustration by the symbols in the outer ring becoming enmeshed together in the inner circle, which itself looks like the symbol for Sol (a circle with a point in the middle). The featured symbols are the alchemical symbols for various planets (which also represent metals), specifically Moon, the Sun, Jupiter, Saturn, Mercury, Mars and Venus. The phrase "it is finished when the seven are one" represents the completion of the Great Work of the alchemist, the achievement of alchemy's holy grail. It also represents a personal transformation, since alchemical philosophy considered transmutation of the inner self to be strongly related to the material-altering aspects of alchemical work. The process of personal transmutation involves the purification of the soul, the integration of inner urges, achievement of balance, and spiritual enlightenment. To complete the Great Work in relation to the self means achieving transcendence.
This connection between changing the material world and changing the self connects to the idea in Holy Wood that if you try to change the world, you'll just end up changing yourself.
Saturn devouring his child
This image appears in Chymica Vannus, an alchemical book written by an unknown author.
The image depicts the Roman/Greek god Saturn devouring his child to prevent the prophesy that his children will one day overthrow him. The idea of parents standing in the way of their children appears not only on Holy Wood, but in Manson's previous work as well.
For easy reading, the text in the image is reproduced below:
CHEMICÆ VANNI
Orbis
SATURNI;
Quòd SaturI color in coronide2 lautâ prodeat urnâ 3 :
Penſum quotidianum.
Outer circle: Natus ut ontne coronari rex poßit in avum.
Inner circle: Non benecum multis veneris lapidisque fit uſus.
Sacellum Saturni
Footer:
I. Hic idem eſt, quod perfectus plenus &c. quiſcilicetnon amplius mutiua, vel inſicitur, ut
aliquid ulterius tinctura admittat.
2. Ie. Infine operis, ſeu corontione ejusdein; dictum ?? corouis idis, quaſi corrona operis.
3. E.e. Ingenti cum quaſi quia urna, ex uſu antiqisorum, ponitur pro magns ſortis delfortuna
lucro & c.
PHŒNICIS five HEL.
Levi's Tetragrammaton Pentagram
This image was created by the French occultist Eliphas Levi, published in his book Dogme et Rituel de la Haute Magie. It is composed of symbols that represent "human existence", and implies that humanity has aspects of divinity by surrounding it with the word "tetragrammaton". The concept was inspired by the work of Heinrich Cornelius Agrippa von Nettesheim, who published a version of the pentagram that represented man as the perfect work of God.
A lot of the symbolism in the image has already been pointed out on the image itself. Here are some additional points:
- Around the pentagram is the word "tetragrammaton", which is Greek for "the four-letter word". It is a reference to the Hebrew word יהוה, which is God's true name, and reads something like "Yahweh", although the true pronunciation is unknown, having been lost to time due to a Jewish superstition against uttering the name.
- The pentagram represents the 4 elements: water, air, earth, and fire, as well as the 5th element, which is spirit. When the top point is facing up, it represents a person, with the top being the head, the tips below it as the arms, and the bottom tips as the legs.
- Notice the many depictions of balance in the image: the alpha and the omega, the moon and the sun, masculine and feminine.
- Next to the letter Omega is the caduceus (two snakes encircling a staff).
The Hebrew letters in the pentagram are a total mess:
- אדמ - the most natural way to read this is Adam, and this is how most people interpret these letters. However, the letters have multiple oddities. The first oddity is that the middle letter actually looks like the letter Reish (ר), not the letter Daled (ד). This is a problem that appears all over Levi's pentagram- there's no proper distinction between ד and ר, and the viewer has to make an educated guess based on knowledge of Hebrew. In this case, since ארמ is meaningless, אדמ is assumed to be the intended meaning. Another oddity is that the last letter (מ) is in its incorrect form: when the letter Mem appears at the end of the word, it's supposed to look like this: ם.
- הוה - it's not entirely clear if these letters are meant to be הוה or הוח. The most common interpretation is that it's הוה, like the tetragrammaton word יהוה but without the first letter. There are reinterpretations of Levi's pentagram that actually feature the full word יהוה instead of the three letters. The הוח option is meaningless when read in the normal direction (right to left), but if you read it in reverse, you get Eve. Since these letters are on the opposite side of the letters for Adam, it's a plausible interpretation in my opinion.
- כתר - Keter, the topmost Sephira. This one is confusing in all three letters. The first letter could be either פ or כ. It's probably supposed to be כ, since the aspects that make it look like פ seem to be part of the "shading" scribbles, but it's not 100% clear which option is correct. The middle letter looks like ח, but if the first letter is indeed כ, then it makes more sense for the second letter to be ת. The last letter could either be ד or ר. Overall, the word that is spelled here could either be פחד, which means fear, or כתר, which is one of the Sephirot. כתר seems to be the most common interpretation.
- כפר - there are multiple ways to read this word. Depending on the context it could mean ransom, village, frost, atonement, or heresy.
The Vacuum(?) of Infinite Space Encompassing All
This is a map of the universe according to Milton's Paradise Lost, as interpreted by Homer B. Sprague. It appeared in an 1879 illustrated edition of the novel. See the song Count To Six And Die for more information.
Visionary Geography in William Blake's Poetry
Alchemy & Mysticism offers the following commentary on this image:
Large parts of William Blake's poetry are concerned with a detailed engagement with Isaac Newton's materialist view of the world, particularly his optics. In Blake's view the physical eye is dull and dim 'like a black pebble in a churning sea,' and the optic nerve, to which Newton pays homage, 'builds stone bulwarks against the raging sea.' (Blake, Milton, 1804) Blake instead turned to the work of Jacon Böhme, and attempted to develop an optics of the visionary.
According to the hypothesis of Easson and Easson, which fails to take into account many aspects of the poetry, every level of Blake's poem 'Milton' is based on an optical model, inscribed within the form of the cosmic egg.
K.P. Easson and R.R. Easson, A hypothetical model for the visionary geography in 'Milton,' from W. Blake, Milton, London, 1979
Explanation of the diagram:
Retina as Eden: the Empyrean, the kingdom of God.
Adam Space: the sphere that contains the world of humanity.
Chamber of vitreous humor as Beulah: "the realm of the Subconscious, the source of poetic inspiration and of dreams." According to Alexander S. Gourlay, a Blake scholar, it is "a dreamy paradise where the sexes, though divided, blissfully converse in shameless selflessness. Beulah is available through dreams and visions to those in Ulro, the utterly fallen world."
Rock of Ages: the Rock of Ages is a Christian hymn, written by Augustus Toplady. The term refers to the strength of God, and the stability and protection this strength provides to his followers.
Golgonooza: a mythical city in the work of William Blake. It is a city of imagination, built by Los. It appears in his poem Jerusalem, and also makes an appearance in the poem Milton.
Mundane Shell: represents the skull in which encloses the brain in which consciousness resides. This is why it's a microcosm.
Iris as Allamanda: The country which supplies sustinance to Golgonooza. The nervous system of the body. Allamanda is also a flower. The Polypus (or polyp) is a term that appears multiple times in Blake's poetry, representing an aquatic living thing.
Bowlahoola: furnaces in the middle of Golgonooza.
Udan-Adan: the name of a lake of space from Blake's The Four Zoas.
Entuthon Benython: a land of Urizen east of Golgonooza. "A dark and unknown night, indefinite, unmeasurable, without end. Abstract Philosophy warring in enmity against Imagination."
Ulro: is the internal condition of blackness, opacity, and darkness which occurs when the Divine Vision is lost.
Jacob's Ladder
This diagram is called Jacob's Ladder. It is composed of 4 repetitions of the Tree of Life (the Kabbalistic diagram of Sephirot), corresponding to the 4 worlds. From top to bottom, the worlds are Atziluth (Emanation/Close), Beriah (Creation), Yetzirah (Formation), Assiah (Action). A fifth world also exists, which comes before the other four. That world is Adam Kadmon, which means the "primal man", the prototype of humanity. Adam Kadmon is considered transcendent above the worlds, and is therefore not represented in Jacob's Ladder. However, he is represented in the Tree of Life's upright position, so in a sense he is still represented in the ladder. He is also considered to be united with the Ein Sof at the top of the ladder, so he is represented in this way as well.
Within the context of Holy Wood, the 4 worlds seem analogous to the 4 sections of the album: in the ladder, the divine emanation begins with Adam at the Ein Sof, and as we descend down the ladder, the emanation takes form and develops into action in the physical world, the Assiah Gishmi, at the very bottom of the ladder. In the Holy Wood track list, we follow a progression of thought that begins with Adam as the story's protagonist, and as we descend down the track list, his thoughts develop into an action in the physical world, the killing of the king, at the very bottom of the track list.
This interpretation helps explain why the 4 sections of the album are prefixed with letters spell ADAM. Just as Adam is a meta-pattern of Jacob's Ladder, so is the name Adam a pattern that emerges across the 4 sections of the album.
Crucifixion In Space
See the song Cruci-Fiction In Space for analysis on this image.
Other illustrations
Distribution on body of suicidal incised wounds and stab wounds over body during 8 year period
Nothing to say about this image, included here for easy reading.
Kennedy's Magic Bullet
This image is from Cover-Up: The Governmental Conspiracy to Conceal the Facts About the Public Execution of John Kennedy by J. Gary Shaw. As the name suggests, this is a conspiracy book that attempts to promote the theory that JFK was not assassinated by a lone nut who acted alone, but was instead an organized act, and that the government covered it up. It advocates for reopening the investigation into the assassination so that we could learn what really happened.
One piece of "evidence" that Gary cites in his book is that the information about the gunshot wounds that Kennedy and Connally sustained doesn't match the information about how many bullets were fired. According to the Warren Commission, which was charged with investigating the assassination, a single bullet wounded both Kennedy and Connally. In the above diagram, Gary claims that the single bullet would have to complete an impossible trajectory in order to injure both Kennedy and Connally the way they were injured.
Tarot
The artwork features redesigns of Tarot cards, most of which are based on the popular Rider-Waite Tarot deck.
The Fool
The Fool represents taking the first step in a journey from innocence to wisdom. It's about new beginnings, endless potential, and walking into the unknown. The fool lacks life experience. He is oblivious to the dangers of the world, setting out on a journey with very little supplies, and doesn't even see the cliff edge he is walking towards. His dog companion is trying to warn him of the danger ahead, but the fool doesn't hear it.
In Manson's version, the fool is one of JFK's secret service guards. Him stepping off a cliff could be interpreted as a metaphor for how oblivious they were of the disaster that was to come (JFK's assassination). The only thing he carries is a poster of JFK, since that is his only concern, and in the back, we see Jackie Onassis. Instead of a dog he has a monkey for a companion, which isn't trying to warn him, unlike the dog.
The Magician
The Magician represents logic and intellect, willpower and manifestation, and the transformation of potential to reality. He is standing in a garden, which represents the manifestation of his desires. In Manson's tarot, the magician seems to be in a cemetery, because in Holy Wood, people's desire is for death. The magician is the conduit between the spiritual and the physical, drawing from the heavens using one hand, and directing it to the earth with the other. Manson's magician lacks the hand pointing down, which could be a reference to the idea that you cannot change the physical world, you can only change yourself.
The magician's staff is his means for connecting with the divine. Manson's connection to the divine is via the crucifix, a symbol of martyrdom. The crucifix Manson is holding has a snake wrapped around it. This has both a biblical meaning, and a conspiratorial one. In the conspiratorial article King Kill 33, James Shelby claims that the killing of JFK was done in order to perform the Killing of The King rite, and that:
in alchemy the Killing of the King was symbolized by a crucified snake on a tau cross, a variant of the crucifixion of Jesus.
--James Shelby Downard, King Kill 33
So, the snake around the cross in Manson's tarot is a veiled reference to JFK. As for the
biblical angle, in Numbers 21:8, God tells Moses: "Make a snake image and mount it on a pole.
When anyone who is bitten looks at it, he will recover". This concept is later echoed in John
3:14-15:
"Just as Moses lifted up the snake in the wilderness, so the Son of Man must be lifted up, so
that everyone who believes in him may have eternal life". In other words, the snake on the
cross is a symbol of physical and spiritual healing.
Finally, notice that Manson's magician is hollow inside. Another card that is hollow inside in Manson's deck is the High Priestess. This connection is not incidental, since the Magician and the High Priestess are each other's counterparts, with the Magician representing classic masculine traits, and the High Priestess representing classic feminine traits. If we interpret the two to be Adam and Eve, we can say that the hole in the Magician is from the part God took out of him to create Eve, while the High Priestess is hollow inside because she is with child, which came from the empty space inside of her.
The High Priestess
The high priestess is about intuition, the subconscious, spiritual insight, inner voice, the divine feminine. She is the guide that lets you step out of rationality, out of established knowledge, out of conscious thought, and into the spiritual realm of the unknown.
Manson's version seems to have very little to do with the Raider-Waite version of the card, because it is actually a reference to its predecessor: The Popess. This card is based on a legend that in the 9th century, a woman named Joan disguised herself as a man in order to join the priesthood to be with her lover, and was able to advance in ranks to eventually be elected pope. She served in that position for two years before her sex was discovered when she gave birth in the middle of a procession. This seems to be the reason why Manson's High Priestess is holding a small human figure (a baby).
Another reference to The Popess is the structure behind Manson's High Priestess. That structure resembles St. Peter's baldachin, which is believed to be located over the tomb of St. Peter, aka the first pope.
The Emperor
The Emperor represent authority, leadership, structure. In one hand he is holding a scepter, which represents authority and power, while the other hand holds an orb, which represents the world the emperor is ruling over. Manson's version doesn't have an orb, but his source of authority and power is a gun. The emperor sits on a stone throne, which represents stability, while Manson's emperor is sitting in a wheelchair, which represents his lack of stability as he clearly can't stand on his own. The emperor's beard represents wisdom; Manson's emperor has no beard.
Instead of a crown, Manson's emperor is wearing a German Pickelhaube helmet, because a ruler in a country of violence is a warmonger. This specific Pickelhaube is adorned with an eagle, which is rooted in The Emperor's symbolism, as older versions of the card used to feature a shield decorated with an eagle. It's worth noting that the Pickelhaube is not a Nazi reference. The use of these helmets was discontinued in the middle of World War I, and the version with the eagle represented Prussia. So, this is not a symbol of fascism, only of war.
The Hierophant
The Hierophant is the card of tradition and convention. He is a teacher figure, symbolizing spiritual wisdom, religion, institutions, and conformity. In other versions of the tarot this card is known as The Pope. Manson's version of the card takes every opportunity to separate itself from the tradition of the Pope, while still remaining rooted in Christian symbolism.
In the original tarot the hierophant is holding a triple cross, also known as the Papal Cross, representing the office of the Pope, religious acumen, and spiritual wisdom. In Manson's tarot the triple cross is part of a dikirion, a 2-candle liturgical candlestick that is used by a bishop of eastern orthodox and eastern catholic churches to bless the faithful. It is usually in conjunction with a trikirion, a 3-candle liturgical candlestick, and arranged such that the dikirion is on the left, and the trikirion is on the right. This is in accordance with Manson holding the dikirion in his left hand.
In the original tarot the hierophant is holding his right hand in a sign of benediction, while Manson's version is an open palm with an eye in the middle, resembling a Hamsa, which is a talisman of protection against evil. Today the Hamsa hand is mostly popular in the middle east, but all major religions adopted some interpretation of the Hamsa, including Christianity where it was dubbed the Hand of Mary. While often stylized as a symmetric hand, with no left or right orientation, it is historically associated with the right hand.
In the original tarot the hierophant's robe is decorated with generic crosses, while Manson's is decorated with the cross of the Knights Templar. The Knights Templar was a French military order of the catholic faith who fought in the crusades and pioneered innovative financial techniques that were an early form of banking, which allowed them to become one of the wealthiest organizations of their times. Their demise came at the start of the 14th century, when the order was violently persecuted by king Philip IV of France, who borrowed a lot of money from the organization and wanted a way to avoid paying it back. As part of his persecution of the templars, king Philip pressured Pope Clements V to disband the order.
In Manson's tarot, the hierophant is standing in front of red stained glass, which represents the blood of Christ, or martyrdom. Also of note is that Manson's version is missing the triple crown that represents the power of the Pope as the father of kings, governor of the world, and vicar of Christ.
The twin keys at the bottom of the original hierophant card, are on the top side of Manson's card. Such changes in direction (left vs right, up vs down) usually represent the opposite of the original meaning. In this case, the meaning of the keys themselves is not altered, but the context in which they appear changes. This is akin to saying: "same message but told my way".
Overall, it seems like Manson's version represents an anti-authoritarian message. It's not opposing the Christian symbolism, it simply refuses to express it using the Pope's orthodoxy, as if saying that the Pope does not have a monopoly on Christianity.
The Hermit
The Hermit represents the spiritual journey that we all take alone. It is a journey fueled by dedication and learned wisdom, one that is already in progress. In contrast, The Fool card represents the beginning of a journey, from the point of lack of wisdom. The lamp that the hermit carries represents the wisdom that lights our path. In Manson's version, this light comes from burning of a prosthetic hand made from twigs, and the hermit is also carrying a supply of twigs on his back, presumably for burning later. This could be symbolic of the light of wisdom that is gained by shedding off the parts of ourselves that are "dead"- no longer working- and the getting rid of "dead wood" (people or things that are no longer useful) that we carry with us.
Justice
The Justice card represents truth, fairness, and law.
Meaningful differences from the original:
- In Manson's version, the scales are not balanced. The bible outweighs the brain.
- The curtain represents the cultural backdrop that colors all ideas of justice. In Manson's version, the cultural backdrop is the crazy world of Holy Wood: America turned upside down.
The Hanged Man
Surprise! The album cover itself can be interpreted as a tarot reference, this time to The Hanged Man card. However, Manson's version isn't actually inspired by the original card, and is simply a depiction of the Crucifixion In Space image (see song Cruci-Fiction In Space for more information). This card does not appear in the album artwork, but it was featured in the set of printed tarot cards that came with The Fight Song single.
Death
The Death card represents an end, transformation, new beginnings. In this case, Manson's version is not based on Rider-Waite's design and is simply a representation of "death is TV", from the song In the Shadow of The Valley of Death. On the TV is a black crow, a bird that is associated with death and misfortune.
The Devil
The devil represents harmful temptations and indulgence in sensual pleasures. It alludes to addiction, greed, lust, and being a slave to the physical world. Manson's version is quite faithful to the original design. Aside from maintaining most of the devil's visual features, it also maintains the key aspects of the people that the devil controls: in the original card, the man and the woman, while looking like humans, do have horns and a tail, which are elements of the devil. It represents the idea that if you stay close to the devil, you'll start becoming like him. In Manson's version, the little girls appear to have legs like those of the devil. In the original card, the man and the woman are chained to the devil, but the chains are loose, and can be easily removed, meaning that the man and woman are really there by choice. Similarly, in Manson's version, the little girls are also free of any bondage, and are staying in the vicinity the devil of their own choice.
The apron that the devil is wearing in Manson's tarot is a Masonic Knights Templar apron. The Freemasons are a religious fraternity that is not strictly Christian, only requiring a belief in a God to be a member. However, the Knights Templar Masonic fraternity is strictly Christian, as were the original Knights Templar. Both the Freemasons and Knights Templar ended up being renounced by the Pope. In the case of the Knights Templar, it was a result of political persecution by king Philip IV of France, who accused the Templars of heresy and pressured Pope V to disband the order. In the case of the Freemasons, Pope Clements XII issued a ban on all Catholics from becoming Freemasons, citing the Freemason's oaths of secrecy as one of the reasons:
"To join these associations is precisely synonymous with incurring the taint of evil and infamy, for if they were not involved in evil doing, they would never be so very averse to the light [of publicity]"".
--Pope Clements XII
This makes the apron both a sign of evil (because of the association with the Freemasons), and a thing that's rooted in Christianity (because of the association with the Knights Templar), much like how the devil is an evil being that is rooted in Christian mythology.
The final difference between Manson's version of the card and the original is the hand gestures. Manson's version uses the hand gestures from Eliphas Levi's Baphomet.
Autopsy video
When the Holy Wood CD is inserted into a computer, it launches a program that plays a short film called Autopsy. This film is inspired by JFK's autopsy.
In both JFK's and Manson's autopsy, the head is open. In Manson's autopsy, a fetus is removed from Manson's head.
This fetus-inside-skull concept seems to be based on the work of William Blake. One of the diagrams that appear in the artwork of Holy Wood depicts the cosmology of William Blake's poetry represented as the anatomy of the eye:
The two parts that are relevant for our analysis are:
Mundane Shell: represents the skull which encloses the brain in which consciousness resides.
...and under the skull is:
Iris as Allamanda (polypus): The Polypus (or polyp) is a term that appears multiple times in Blake's poetry, representing an aquatic living thing. Blake's poetry also refers to the fetus as a polyp-like creature.
...the combination of the two gives us a fetus inside the head.
What is the point of the fetus in the head? Since it's being removed from a corpse, it's for all intents and purposes an aborted fetus. Perhaps this is meant to remind us of the tragedy of the situation. An adult man killed, is a child who did not live up to their full potential.
Beyond The Record
The Holy Wood era yielded 4 singles, 4 music videos, a live DVD and Blue Ray, and 1 original B-Side (Diamonds & Pollen). There was also a Holy Wood novel that Manson wrote but was unable to release.
Singles
Disposable Teens
The Disposable Teens single features a sketch at the bottom right. It is taken from JFK's autopsy report.
The Fight Song
There were two versions for The Fight Song single artwork, one featuring Manson-as-Adam aiming a rifle, and one of Manson with a TV, a closeup of the Death tarot card from the album artwork. The image on the TV is the infamous frame 313 from the Zapruder Film, which shows the exact moment when JFK is shot in the head. The round sketch that appears in both versions is a sketch of JFK's head wound as seen from above, made by Dr. Boswell during the autopsy.
B-Sides
Diamonds & Pollen
This song appeared on one of the Disposable Teens singles. It's a very odd song, which uses a bunch of metaphors that Manson never used before, nor since. It also draws lyrical inspiration from Manson's previous album, Mechanical Animals. This makes me suspect that it is an early song in the Holy Wood era, written before the motifs and metaphors of Holy Wood were fully fleshed out.
The song is written like the contemptuous confession of someone who is nihilistic and hates existence, and who just carried out a Columbine-style massacre.
Lyrics | Commentary |
---|---|
America bled to death Electric and pregnant Brilliant sluts and fire worship Devouring the righteous | We start by setting a scene.America bled to death While this could be a description of America being destroyed, it becomes clear further down in the lyrics it that this isn't the intended meaning, because there's no further mention of a full apocalypse, and instead we even have a description of life carrying on (like a coroner who investigates the event). So, what this probably means, is: a violent death happened, and it was felt nation-wide (possibly because it was televised), hence it's as if all of America bled to death along with the victim(s). Electric and pregnant It's hard to tell what electric is supposed to mean, but an educated guess could be the concept of "electric information". The media analyst Marshall McLuhan, which Manson has a well-documented fascination with, described the age of radio, film, and TV as the "electric [information] age". Since Manson often describes society as being glued to its TV screens, it's possible that describing America as "electric" is an allusion to McLuhan's work. Pregnant is a metaphor for being full and about to burst. For example, pregnant skies would be skies full of dark clouds that are about to burst out with rain. So, one interpretation could be that America is overabundant, so prosperous that it's about to burst from all of its wealth. This interpretation implies some resentful undertones on the part of the speaker. Alternatively, we can try to examine the pregnancy related metaphors in the Holy Wood era: the pregnant girl in Valentine's Day with her dead fetus, and the fetus-in-head images of the Autopsy film and artwork outtakes. The overarching theme in these examples is dead children, which on the album represent people who are destined to a terrible end. Maybe there's something about America that keeps birthing the Oswalds, the Mark Davids, the Charles Mansons, the Eric Harrises, and the Dylan Klebolds of the world, and we were due for another one right now. Brilliant sluts and fire worship "Brilliant sluts" sounds like a throwback to Mechanical Animals, where Hollywood is the city sex and glamour. Fire worship is the worship of something destructive. Devouring the righteous Looks like there's no way to be good in this world. |
We were just monkeys braiding thread We were golden needles Diamonds and pollen | The following interpretation might be a bit out there, but I think "braiding thread" might
be referring to the DNA thread. DNA is a coil of two threads, and when a child is conceived,
each parent contributes one half of that coil. So "monkeys breading thread" could mean
"monkeys procreating". This idea segues elegantly into the next line: a needle is something
that guides a thread during sewing, so this could be a metaphor for the parents guiding
their children, the threads they braided earlier. Why are they golden? We know that Manson
took inspiration from the end of the 60s, which is the time when the baby boomers started
reaching adulthood. The baby boomer generation ended up being one of the wealthiest
generations in American history, hence they are golden. Hence, they are diamonds. The phrase "Diamonds and Pollen" sounds like a play on the famous Prince song Diamonds and Pearls (Manson previously covered a Prince song live during the Antichrist Superstar era, so it's not outside the realm of possibility that this is a Prince reference). Pollen is a powder that bees spread around to create new flowers, so it works as a metaphor for procreation, which is fitting for the baby boomer generation. It also ties in with the end of the song, where Manson talks about "grow and to die like flowers do". |
And Coma White A manniqueen of depression The face of a Dead Star Fagged out for the coroner She was so soft in my bed | Coma White is a song and character from the album Mechanical Animals. A star who was
traumatized by the city of glamour and is now using drugs to cope.A manniqueen of depression These lines are from the song Mechanical Animals. On the Mechanical Animals album, there is no clear connection between the person described in these lines and the character of Coma White, but this song seems to be making this connection, and this description is on-theme for the Coma character as we know her from the album Mechanical Animals. Fagged out for the coroner This section reveals that Coma was the shooter's girlfriend, which might be why the coroner is visiting her. She is exhausted from… grief? Stress? Or is this just her normal state of being due to her trauma? |
And the pomegranate earth spins into oblivion | The pomegranate is a symbol of abundance and fertility. The contrast with all the contempt that precedes this line makes me think it is said sarcastically, like: "and this great world of yours keeps on spinning". It's flying into oblivion because for our speaker there is nothing good in the world, so the future holds nothing but oblivion. |
The one that trembles The one that fears The one that suffers The one that vomits The one that needs | Multiple people, all showing signs of distress. This could be the narrator recalling the terror he invoked in people during his shooting spree, much like how the Columbine killers took pleasure in watching their hostage schoolmates in the high school library trembling with fear. |
A million scars, a million promises | Every unfulfilled promise is a scar. Our narrator has been hurt by society's deception. |
And all your sad endings are planting in their gardens And they're waiting to grow and to die like flowers do | There's an idea on Holy Wood (which also appears on Antichrist Superstar), that children often end up paying for the traumas of their parents, because they have to grow up in the parents' coping mechanisms, which aren't really oriented towards the best of the children. This is what I think the idea in this section is. The sad endings in the parents' lives end up planting the seeds for the children's failures. |
The Love Song Bon Harris remix
The Bon Harris remix of The Love Song has some added content not present in the original song. A man is heard delivering the following monologue:
Lyrics | Commentary |
---|---|
Man: Music that began with a fanfare of thundering drums... Music that inflamed people's
wild patriot fervor... Clerk: 12 dollars...78 cents Man: machine guns... Clerk: 12 dollars...78 cents Man: mountains of human corpses | It's unknown where these voices are from, but we do know based on a tour poster for the Rape of The World tour (in support of the album Eat Me, Drink Me), that $12.78 is a reference to the price of the 6.5 Italian Carbine rifle that Oswald used to assassinate JFK. |
Man: They found that music can help incite beast-like behavior... arouse the desire to kill. killing...break...kill...killing | |
12 dollars and 78 cents to rock the world |
Disposable Teens Bon Harris remix
The Bon Harris remix of Disposable Teens has some additional content.
Samples
- At the beginning of the track there's a backmasked sample. When reversed, it is revealed to be
a speech from the movie Planet of The Apes:
"Beware the beast man, for he is the devil's pawn. Alone among God's primates, he kills for sport, or lust or greed. Yea, he will murder his brother to possess his brother's land. Let him not breed in great numbers, for he will make a desert of his home and yours. Shun him. Drive him back into his jungle lair: For he is the harbinger of death". - "Children were executed", "get in the fire". Source unknown.
- "Jesus loves the little children, all the little children of the world".
This sample previously appeared on the song Revelation #9. It's from the Christian children's song Jesus Loves The Little Children, originally composed by George Frederick Root.
Music videos
Disposable Teens
The beast and crucifixion in space
In the biblical book of Daniel, we have descriptions of 4 beasts, each one coming from the sea. The fourth beast is described in Daniel 7:
After that, in my vision at night I looked, and there before me was a fourth beast—terrifying frightening and very powerful. It had large iron teeth; it crushed and devoured its victims and trampled underfoot whatever was left. It was different from all the former beasts, and it had horns.
--Daniel 7:7
The opening scene in Disposable Teens has Manson rising from the water with what looks like iron teeth. He rises to tremendous height that certainly allows him to "trample victims underfoot", and he has long strands of hair, which could represent might, like in the story of Samson, whose power came from his long hair.
Once Manson reaches his full height, he opens up his hand in a crucifixion position, against the backdrop of dark skies. This is a reference to the Crucifixion In Space imagery that is discussed in the song Cruci-Fiction In Space. This scene has become a feature of the God Guns And Government tour, where it was common for Manson to perform Cruci-Fiction In Space while being lifted up on a rising platform, just like in the music video.
The False Prophet
In this scene, we see Manson wearing lamb skin. He also has a silver Tau cross on his face, which represents the crucifixion. Although this could be mistaken for a representation of the Lamb of God, there are key features that contradict this interpretation. First, he is sitting on a throne. In the book of Revelation, where we meet the lamb as a lamb, rather than as a man, the lamb is never depicted as sitting on a throne. It is always in the midst of the throne, never on the actual throne, which is occupied by God. Second, Manson's depiction has what looks like wings of meat, which is another feature that's uncharacteristic of the lamb. The meat wings do resemble the meat wings that appear on Manson's version of The Devil tarot card. This leads me to conclude that what we are seeing here is a depiction of the false prophet, as warned about in Matthew 7: "Beware of false prophets, which come to you in sheep's clothing, but inwardly they are ravening wolves".
Christianity
Another scene features Manson dressed like the Pope standing in front of a cross, with a monkey hanging on the cross.
The painting behind Manson depicts John the Baptist baptizing the Neophytes in the river Jordan, and is from a series of paintings called Scenes From The Life of St John The Baptist, located in the Oratory of St John the Baptist in Italy. It was painted by Italian painters Lorenzo and Jacopo Salimbeni.
The painting in the Disposable Teens video is covered in scribbles, which include:
- "And I'm the ape of God"
- "You say you want a revolition[sic]" written in a speech bubble coming out of one of the characters.
- "Sixteen knives"
- "68¢T"
- "Altmont" (probably a misspelling of Altamont)
- "Fig. four and five"
The monkey that is hanging on the cross in Disposable Teens is of course a reference to the theme of evolution and ape vs. man that runs through the album, but it also directly references Jesus, because later in the video we see a recreation of the famous painting The Last Supper, where the role of Jesus is once again played by the monkey:
The Fight Song
The music video for The Fight Song depicts a high school football game between goths and jocks, the eternal high school enemies. The scoreboard shows that the game is between teams Holy Wood and Death Valley. Football is very popular in America, and is a rather violent sport, so this choice of competition further demonstrates Manson's point that American culture is steeped in violence. Adding to the violent theme is the school mascot, who is brandishing two guns, while the cheerleaders provide the sexual aspect of the entertainment. The game stops when a kid from Death Valley rebels against the situation and blows up the scoreboard.
The Nobodies
In an interview with Metal Edge, Manson described the concept of the video as follows:
In the music video, Manson plays the devil, and also some kind of pagan guardian of the forest. The strict and oppressive environment that the orphanage guardians create lead the orphans to not only escape, but also to seek the devil for protection.
The devil decides to help the children get revenge on their guardians and visits the orphanage. First, he confronts the dog, who senses who he is and acts hostile towards him. Then he meets the guardians, who are both holding a picture of an eye in front of Manson, as if using it as a talisman of protection. This might be in reference to the Evil Eye talisman. The Evil Eye superstition is the belief that a malevolent gaze can invoke a curse. The Nazar is a talisman that protects against the Evil Eye, and it itself looks like an eye.
The devil disarms the guardians of their apprehension by throwing some money their way. The guardians are apparently so greedy that they'll gladly kiss the hand of anyone who pays them, even if that someone is the devil. As they get down on the floor to collect the coins, they are ensnared by twigs, presumably thanks to the powers of the pagan lord they met earlier. They are pulled into a grinder and turned into dirt, which the orphans and the devil eat. The transformation to dirt might be in reference to the theological idea that humans are of the earth, and when we die, we are made one with the earth again. Ashes to ashes, dust to dust.
The orphans eating the guardians can be seen as a subversion of fairytale expectations, where it is usually the orphans that (almost) get eaten by an evil character whom they encounter.
The dinner scene at the end of the music video features 3 paintings. One of them is too obscured to identify, but the other two are not. The painting in the bottom right is Saturn Devouring His Son by Francisco Goya. The painting hanging from the wall is Tiger Hunt by Eugene Delacroix. Goya's painting represents parents standing in the way of their children, while Eugene's painting represents a scene of violence.
Tainted Love
Both the music video and the decision to cover a song like Tainted Love were very unusual choices for Manson. Manson commented on this in a post to his official BBS (a Bulletin Board System, the predecessor of online forums):
"I hope everyone was able to enjoy the seething sarcasm in the video and notice that it was just plain entertaining to those of us who made it. As I am between records, I really felt the music world needed something a little less serious right now. If you don't get it or like it, that's your call".
The Tainted Love music video is based on the parody movie Not Another Teen Movie. It co-stars the movie's original cast, who reprise their roles from the film. In the music video, Manson and his goth friends crash a high school party that takes place in the house of the lead cheerleader Priscilla. The nerdy Janey Briggs, who was the main protagonist in the movie, gets a little story arc that mirrors the one from the movie. In the movie, Jake Wyler, the most popular boy in school, transforms Janey from a nerdy "freak with glasses and ponytail" to an attractive girl, and in the music video Manson, the most popular boy in the goth party, inspires her to transform to an attractive goth girl.
The car Manson arrives in is a modified Lincoln Continental, from the same lineup as the model JFK was riding when he was assassinated.
The goth-rapper version of Manson seems to be inspired by Ali G, a satirical character played by Sasha Baron Cohen that was a parody of "suburban, privileged youth acting in a way that they think is typical of black people". Ali G was at the height of his popularity in 2001, the year Manson released Tainted Love.
Another reference cultural reference in the video is to Hugh Hefner, the founder of Playboy magazine, whose trademark look included wearing a bathrobe as part of his formal attire. Women who worked in Playboy nightclubs were known as "bunnies", wearing sexy costumes and bunny ears.
Holy Wood novel
The Holy Wood novel was based on the Holy Wood album, but also on the triptych as a whole. It featured characters such as Adam, who is a musician, Coma White, the president's daughter, and Valentine, who seems to be the president's advisor. The novel was never published, and the details on why were never fully revealed. In a post made by Manson in The Oracle section of his website, Manson said that:
The book has been written for over 3 years, but the censorship of certain ideas, ideals and opinions has kept me from releasing it to the public. I'm sorry I can't say more, but there is a religious objection to its release because the story's inspiration was not only my own life (the three albums included) but also some "private" documents I discovered. This is a deep and dark road, and I haven't found the off-ramp.
It is rumored that the religious objection came from the Church of Scientology.
Over the years Manson expressed interest in releasing it, or turning it into a movie, but none of these plans materialized. To date, the only thing that was ever released was chapter 10 of the novel, which Manson posted on thisasvalentinesday.com as a 2001 Valentine's Day gift to the fans, and the cover art. In an interview with the fan site The Hierophant, Manson confirmed that the arrangement of the guns and text in the novel's cover was meant to evoke the shape of the Cross of Lorraine (depicted in red), which Manson initially adopted as the symbol for the Celebretarian Corporation, and later for himself.
Tour
The tour for the album was called God Guns and Government. Some of the Holy Wood themed elements of the show included a mic stand shaped like a rifle, the Pope outfit from the Disposable Teens music video, Manson recreating the crucifixion in space image by being lifted up on a rising platform during the song Cruci-Fiction In Space, and the podium that is used on the song Antichrist Superstar was redesigned with a crucifix of guns.
Perhaps the most interesting and surprising theatrical element was Manson entering the stage on a steampunk version of a Roman chariot, pulled by two women with horse heads. Manson is also wearing a Roman helmet with 5 horns and a skull-and-crossbones.
This is most likely a reference to the Roman Caesar Nero, who was the first Caesar to persecute the Christians, punishing them in various cruel ways, including feeding them to the lions. The case for this being a reference to Nero can be found in an interview quote from the Holy Wood era:
Although Manson named the wrong Caesar, the fact remains that a Roman emperor who is known for feeding Christians to the lions was on his mind during that time. Years later, in the High End of Low era, Manson started comparing himself in interviews to Nero again (this time using the correct name), so clearly, it's a character that caught his attention.
The Death Song bible speech
During the God Guns and Government tour, Manson was once again the target of many protests, particularly from Christian groups. For his Denver, Colorado show, he announced on his website that he would balance his show by reading from the bible, saying that "This way, fans will not only hear my so-called 'violent' point of view, but we can also examine the virtues of wonderful 'Christian' stories of disease, murder, adultery, suicide and child sacrifice. Now that seems like 'entertainment' to me.
That bible reading appears on The Nobodies single as an intro to The Death Song.
Denver, Colorado, it's been a long time coming And you're the best fuckin' crowd I've seen all my life There's a lot of people standin' outside tonight Holdin' this fuckin' book right here And they wanna tell me that they care more about you then I do So I think for those people outside can I hear a 'fuck you' And like I promised I said I would read from the bible Now let me ask you a question Does this sound like it's very offensive to young people? For every one that curses his father or his mother He shall surely be put to death And that's not all brothers and sisters And if we can turn our bibles to psalms Happy shall he be that taketh and dasheth the little ones against the stones So let me ask you a question, who is a worse influence? God or Marilyn Manson And if that is not the best fuckin' example God himself killed his own motherfuckin' son So let's sing the death song kids |